The issue of Fadak

[Crescent]

Re: The issue of Fadak

@aqeel123

So Aisha can go on a war against Imam Ali a.s when Quran commanded her to stay home but she cannot tell a lie ?

U can decide who is included in Ahley-bait in 33:33, but its certainly not someone who went against Quran.

and for sake of people u love.... plz stick to the topic :), its not a "y shias hate enemies of ahleybait (a.s)" debate; its abt fidak.

And the Prophet pbuh MARRIED and LOVED a person who went against Quran? Ali r.a. married his family to her family?

So, its more subjective than objective? This is what Quran tells us to do?

The topic can't be more clear than that, the hatred for those who were "enemies" has become pinnacle for the shias. Its fadak, succession, kerbala, etc that continue to divide the ummah.