Re: The issue of Fadak
Crescent, once again you did not refute any of the point I mentioned hwich means whatever I had written stand correct.
Now coming to what you have posted, and seriously that has taken us off topic:
Sorry to say but that is not plausible at all, deeming that Fatima Zahra [sa] would tell a lie just for a land is something not plausible at all.
No sir, Ayesha herself has testified in Sahih Muslim about those who were made pure in 33:33 and at no point did she claim that she was also included in those being purified, if I am saying anything wrong here, then you are most welcome to correct me. But again, that is not the topic of this thread and we can still discuss Fadak without even discussing 33:33.
What? Please do not be like the typical SSP people, like we have been observing ALIJAN1001 here, who would just comment on a thing that was never claimed by the opponent, where in my any post did I claim that Fatima cursed Abu Bakar? That si the reason with some people that they do not understand the point that is being conveyed to them, my point was, that Allah [swt] chose Fatima Zahra [as] among those who would curse the lairs, that means she did not have the tendency of telling a lie - an indrect guarantee by Allah [swt], and now someone asking her to bring witness is like refuting her truthfulness.
She did not talk to Abu Bakar and departed this world in an angry state with Abu Bakar [Sahih Bukhari Volume 4, Book 53, Number 325], what more of the level do you want from her?
Can you point out one such post here wherein anyone has cursed someone? Why are you trying your best to go off topic by bringing all sorts of irrelevant things here?
If that is the case, then to paraphrase your own post:
I am sorry to get so upset, but this is reality. His householdmean a lot to Shias, and we seriously frown upon anyone hurting them.
Aisha r.a. would never tell a lie either. She had been defended by the Quran also. Yet Shias curse her day and night, and then you're asking me who is cursing who?
That is a response to half of your post, the other half, well please read Psyah's post regarding Fatima a.s. The Princess of Jannah.