The Influence of Birth Order

The Influence of Birth Order - MSN Health & Fitness - Health Topics

This is an amazing article i found on MSN parenting page n the following is a random comment of a reader..

I am a middle child too between two sisters. just reading few of the experiences made me relate to my own. Since the time i could remember i knew that i wasn’t loved by my mom & my dad wasn’t ever strong enough to stand up to her while my sisters couldn’t relate to how i felt. My eldest sister being the perfect child she always over shadowed me in every way (grades ,looks, manners etc..) no matter how much i tried, for my mother to say i had done well. it dint come out easily for her & her silence or unable to compliment spoke more than she could ever speak to me without arguing. Therefore early on i learnt to snatch. The partiality at my home was obvious, I got immune. It became a competition for me to win something making my mom loose the satisfaction that she’s won, therefore when i couldn’t get stuff or i knew i was treated unfairly i snatched it. The constant effort to be one step ahead made me a worse person. i could feel it, not only i had become rude & blunt i was destroying myself to prove something to my mom which i know she wouldn’t ever realize. I truly loved my dad but my dad loved everybody equally, truth is he was never able to stand up for me so eventually even without me realizing i had withdrawn from him too. I was fortunate enough to find my love early on in life & being steady but all this has caused me unwillingly to not trust on unconditional love. I pray that one day I can move past all this & make peace with it all and feel secure that love doesn’t have to be for a reason because I am tired of asking him “why do u love me so much” & no matter what he says nothing ever to satisfy my heart.

What advice would u give the the person above as a parent? what would u do differently that ur kids dunt feel the same way?

I've read an article that said that some parents do have a favorite child and that the children can guess correctly who the favorite is.......and some of these parents have even admitted to having a favorite.

^I don't know how true the article is.................and it can't speak for ALL parents.

Sometimes what we think of "favoritism" is really just the parent's way of accommodating to the child's needs. Each child is different...........has different needs........and cannot be treated the same as another child. "Fair" DOES NOT always mean "Equal." For example......it would actually be unfair to have equal expectations of a student that is bright and one that has a learning disability. I'm not saying that the person in question has any sort of disability. Parent can treat children differently based upon their temperaments as well.

Perhaps the reader's parents felt that she was more stronger and independent compared to her siblings....maybe they had greater trust in her. Maybe they felt that the other children were more needy/dependent and required more attention.

She might think that life was easy for the her eldest sibling......but maybe the reality is different. It's not surprising that the eldest sibling developed faster. Obviously, when you're the oldest ......you will graduate first, drive the car first, experience life's various phases first. WHY? Because you're the eldest..........and it's not your fault that Mommy and Daddy had you first. The reader needs to separate issues that can be controlled and those that can't. She can't harbor a grudge toward her older sister for being born first and experiencing things earlier than her. That is a given.

I've also read that many times the "favored" child is the one that is under sooooooooo much stress from all the expectations the parents have of him/her. Perhaps her sister (even though she didn't show it) was under constant pressure to "do well" from her parents. That's not a healthy situation to be in. ** Sometimes not being under the spot light allows you greater amount of freedom and breathing room. **So, you feel that your sister is prettier. Looks are subjective and beauty is in the eye of the beholder. Perhaps some people might find HER prettier than the older sister. And your sister can't control the way that she looks.........she's born with the face and body she has.......and she's doing nothing wrong by maintaining herself. So, she gets better grades than you. Everyone's mind works differently.....everyone has different studying habits. Perhaps her study habits were more effective. So, she had good manners. Everyone has a different personality. Some people are more extroverted......others are introverted. Some are mild-mannered.....others are loud and brash. Some are conscious of the way others view them and make the effort to behave properly.............and others are comfortable in their own skin and don't want to change themselves. Everyone is different. There's nothing wrong in recognizing positive qualities in others and trying to emulate them....but one shouldn't have to compromise their entire personality. The reader needs to assess whether her negative emotions toward her sister are valid.

Perhaps Dad was a "people pleaser" and the kind of person who would NEVER stand up for anyone because conflicts made him uncomfortable. Maybe mom saw much of her own self in the older siblings and pressured them to succeed. Maybe the parents' demands for success and criticism are simply a reflection of their own insecurities. Parents are not perfect.

Her parents might have hurt her.........but it's possible that she's been spared a lot of grief from their frequent attention as well such as the pressure of being under the spot light all the time.

They're not perfect........but they've shaped her into the individual that she is today. A stone gets polished to smoothness with the rough waters and harsh weather that it encounters. Her parents....have contributed to her development and knowledge. She now knows the importance of giving attention to all of one's children. Perhaps her experience will enable her to become a better mother. Perhaps her experience has taught her to become more independent.......to have a tougher skin. Many times, our negative experiences teach us more than our positive ones. In spite of her past hurts......if she reflects over issues.......she might even be able to thank her parents for making her stronger/better/wiser in some ways.

She has one set of parents......they're irreplaceable. She can choose to either dwell on the negative all her life......or also try to appreciate the positive. She can even try to forgive them because all humans, including herself, are imperfect and have hurt others. A well-known psychologist says that healthy love does not necessarily have to come only from parents. If your parents were unable to give you the love that you needed...........then don't be so dependent upon them.........reflect over the people who do give you the love and support you need such as your spouse, siblings, children, friends, etc. Life will not end just because one or two people couldn't fully meet your emotional needs.

I'd also like to add that I don't think that the "Birth Order" theory is one that is definite......or that is defines people accurately. There are so many factors that influence one's personality.

For example.......let's consider culture and gender. In our desi culture.......let's say that a family has three siblings and the child in the MIDDLE is the ONE AND ONLY SON. Now that changes things because desi culture puts greater values on sons. Perhaps this** MIDDLE CHILD** will receive GREATER ATTENTION from parents because of his gender.

Similarly maybe the middle child who is the ONLY DAUGHTER in the family will be more pampered than the other children who are boys.

Maybe the middle child..........who has a disability.......will receive greater attention than the eldest and youngest siblings who are healthy and normal.

See what I mean........too many factors influence things here

Re: The Influence of Birth Order

I was the middle child for 12 years but I never felt they way you describe. Yes, elder sister is seen as the responsible one but I think I might actually be the favourite one.
I really hope now that my siblings don't feel that my mom loves them less cause I know my parents love us all equally and all or our strengths.
I really hope you are able to grow out of this feeling and there are no negative feelings between you and your parents InshAllah!

Re: The Influence of Birth Order

Did you ever try talking to your mom about this issue? I felt less loved by my mother but I was wrong all the way, the realization came a bit late but I am glad it did.

Re: The Influence of Birth Order

I suffer from the middle child syndrome - hoho :D

Not