The hoax with a positive outcome

There is definitely Islamophobia around and last week in Sydney the #I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) 'llridewithyou got support from both all around Australia and the world. It inspired lot of people to post similar messages. There were even a number of songs made on the basis of this hashtag. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHY9Pro7x_s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QbboBkIaPw

Obviously it had a positive impact. Would you feel cheated that the original “feel good” story that was quoted by many was not true? What do you feel about such hoaxes even if they ultimately have good impact? If it happened in your city what would be your response?

This was the original tweet by Rachael Jacobs. #I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) llRideWithYou: Sydney Stands Up To Racism And Bigotry With One Beautiful Hashtag | Gizmodo Australia

All other tweets related to this by other people seem reliable.

This is her confession.

So the lady who wrote the tweet watched a stranger take off her headscarf(she is not sure if it was a hijab), wanted to engage her in conversation and wanted to walk with her from the station to show her support but no words came out.
**I feel like maybe she really wanted to make more Muslim friends and find out about Islamophobia so she made this tweet. So if you wear hijab/have a beard and a non-Muslim wanted to befriend you in a train/public transport, how would you recommend people like Rachael Jacobs etc to approach you in a friendship way? **

What I did on a Brisbane train that stoked#I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) llridewithyou – Quartz

What I did on a Brisbane train that stoked #I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) llridewithyou

http://img.qz.com/2014/12/ap249958408924.jpg?w=940

Let’s all ride with each other. (AP Photo/Steve Christo)
SHARE

WRITTEN BY

Rachael JacobsLecturer, Australia Catholic University
December 16, 2014

As news of the siege unfolded, I scrolled through updates on my phone, searching for the latest information. My brother works in the city of Sydney. My husband’s office is a government building near Martin Place. I knew all were safe and sound, but I wanted to know more.

**At this point I saw a woman on the train start to fiddle with her headscarf.

Confession time. In my Facebook status, I editorialised. She wasn’t sitting next to me. She was a bit away, towards the other end of the carriage. Like most people she had been looking at her phone, then slowly started to unpin her scarf.

Tears sprang to my eyes and I was struck by feelings of anger, sadness and bitterness. It was in this mindset that I punched the first status update into my phone, hoping my friends would take a moment to think about the victims of the siege who were not in the cafe.

I spent the rest of the journey staring—rudely—at the back of her uncovered head. I wanted to talk to her, but had no idea what to say. Anything that came to mind seemed tokenistic and patronising. She might not even be Muslim or she could have just been warm! Besides, I was in the “quiet carriage” where even conversation is banned.**

By sheer fluke, we got off at the same station, and some part of me decided saying something would be a good thing. Rather than quiz her about her choice of clothing, I thought if I simply offered to walk her to her destination, it might help.

It’s hard to describe the moment when humans, and complete strangers, have a conversation with no words. I wanted to tell her I was sorry for so many things—for overstepping the mark, for making assumptions about a complete stranger and for belonging to a culture where racism was part of her everyday experience.

**
But none of those words came out, and our near silent encounter was over in a moment.**

My second status was written as a heartbreaking postscript to my first. While the woman appeared to appreciate my gesture, we had both left defeated and deflated. What good is one small action against an avalanche of ignorance?

Hours later, social media showed me good people can create their own avalanche of kindness.

My posts were written on my private Facebook page to a private audience, never intended for public eyes. A friend of mine made his own decision to share it publicly, and I’m deeply humbled by his action. Perhaps the story was then shared widely because it represented what so many people felt in their heart. But while I’m warmed by the sheer volume of media interest, I am not the story here, and my actions were not extraordinary or heroic.

We are all in shock at the tragedy that has unfolded, and out of respect for the victims’ families, I’m reluctant to take any media focus.

I’ve made the decision to decline interviews for a few reasons. I have spent some time in the public eye due to my recent experiences as a candidate in federal and local elections. I would be mortified if anyone thought I was using this tragedy for political gain.

I’m also a teacher and lecturer and have a responsibility to represent my profession and institution. At a time of heightened emotions, a misplaced word or phrase could cause offence, requiring numerous explanations and reassurances.

But most importantly, my role in this movement was minuscule and unworthy of the attention received. The #I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) llridewithyou hashtag, started by Twitter user @sirtessa and embraced by thousands, is the real story of inspiration. The movement has inspired thousands to publicly and loudly stand up for a decent and humane world. It’s a pre-emptive strike against racism and bigotry. We know what fear can do to a society, and rather than fall victim, thousands have pledged to be part of the force that fights for tolerance and compassion.

As we grapple with the tragic end to the siege, there’s no better time to ride with each other, walk with each other, listen to each other or just silently be there for someone else.

Our grief as a nation will be overwhelming and we will be confounded as we try to make sense of this event. It will be tempting to search for answers in politics or beliefs, sheltering in the irrational fear that more madness is to come.

**
But #I](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/usertag.php?do=list&action=hash&hash=I) llridewithyou reminds us that we can overcome fear and ignorance with a pledge to treat each other with respect. It’s a reminder that decent Australians don’t hold an entire group of people responsible for the actions of one man.
**

Some claim the movement is patronising, forcing misplaced support upon those who need space, rather than spotlight. They may have a point. But there’s no doubting its good intentions. And perhaps we need it more for ourselves as a reminder that there are reasoned and tolerant people that walk among us, publicly disempowering the trolls.

One of the most common questions I’ve been asked is “Do you have a message for the Muslim community?”

In truth, I don’t. They are a strong community with their own articulate leaders, able to speak for themselves if they choose to do so.

I am, however, the daughter of Indian migrants, and having lived all of my 37 years in Australia, I feel I’ve seen the best and the worst this country has to offer. I’d rather deliver a message to racists, bigots and anyone who dares to derive a message of hate from this tragedy—it is you who are unwelcome here. Your values have no place in civilised society, and if you spread intolerance, there’s an avalanche of kindness ready to take you down.

*Republished with permission from Fairfax Syndication. *

Re: The hoax with a positive outcome

It wasn’t a complete hoax as she did see a female with a headscarf on a train and pondered a lot of questions. She had posted it on her personal account but one of her caucasian friends saw it and posted it without permission then it went viral. Apparently, she’s not even white but daughter of Indian migrants who migrated 37 years ago.

Sydney siege: #illridewithyou raises questions about Facebook privacy

Michael James

Rachael Jacobs’ experience on a Brisbane train inspired the #illridewithyou campaign during the Sydney cafe siege.* Photo: Supplied

I have a very private facebook account. Many people do these days. Often these accounts are established under altered identities to protect our privacy, security or just to appease that underlying sense of paranoia many feel on the internet.
Rachael Jacobs has a private account too. As a person who has been in the media eye before, it is rather essential for her. Rachael and I became friends through circumstance and a chance encounter several years ago. I’ve always admired her for her strength, tenacity and ability to think clearly and passionately.

#illridewithyou: online users continue to tweet their support for the local Muslim community.

On Monday afternoon, I let her down.

The thing about private social media accounts is we set them up for a reason. Most of the time our friends know they are set to private. It gives us a safe space to express ourselves freely without impinging on our professional lives and gives us some digital breathing space to post what we please without fear of reprisal.
On Monday, I spotted the posts Rachael made about her experience on the train and, without thinking, I acted. I took that information, inspired and moved by her actions, and I put it out on Twitter without a second thought for her privacy and her motives. Rachael has a Facebook page and a Twitter account. If she had wanted the wider public to view her story she would have placed it there. Instead I took that decision out of her hands. My intentions were pure. I wanted to share a lovely story and hers was lovely, resonating with hundreds of thousands of people.

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/content/dam/images/1/2/a/i/f/r/image.related.articleLeadNarrow.300x0.12agyg.png/1419045019993.jpg

Michael James* Photo: Supplied*

What followed was an avalanche of goodwill amongst the public. She was heaped with praise and lauded for her good deed. However, she also found herself unwillingly thrust into the media spotlight in the midst of a dramatic, confrontational and controversial event unfolding in the mainstream media.
As I’ve watched it unfold I’ve seen the love and the hate towards her on social media. *(How #illridewithyou began with Rachael Jacobs' experience on a Brisbane train) to the incident and my heart smiled, then sank. My actions forced her to speak out and become involved in the dialogue, something she never wanted or asked for.
She’s never once blamed me. Her humility and good nature is too kind for that. She’s taken the matter in her stride and moved forward, but for me this has posed a wider question.
How much should we respect people’s right to post private information on social media?
This story goes a long way to show just how public your personal information can be spread. One post and 24 hours later the whole world is knocking on your door. For someone who didn’t ask for that, is it fair?
It’s easy enough to know when someone has posted something publicly or privately. The mediums through which we choose to post our content are generally indicative of this. When we know someone has a private social media account are we obligated to contain this information or should we simply have to “suck it up” if someone else chooses to share it?
It’s an important question and one we need to consider before we launch into sharing other people’s information. Could there be legal consequences arising from actions such as this? If the story had gone in a different direction, if Rachael had lost of her job or worse yet been abused or attacked in person, where would the responsibility and the liability sit? I could have easily found myself sitting in a court room defending my actions. Despite all the good to come of this situation there are definitely consequences to be considered.
It is a fair thought worth considering - just what are you exposing someone to when you share their information on social media?
*Michael James is a freelance writer and radio reporter/producer based in Brisbane. You can find him on Twitter @**Michael**james_tv *
*

Re: The hoax with a positive outcome

I feel that there should be more awareness of the different types of hijabs/head coverings among non-Muslims in the community so it can be better appreciated.

Not all headscarves are burkas: 7 types of Muslim headwear for women | 22 Words