Re: The family of Ali KaramAllaho Wajho at the battle of Karbala
*Now lets come back to Yazeed, Even though their were Yazids in List of 72 shuhada of Karbala.... I would prefer not naming my kids Yazeed because when someone says Yazid I think fo Yazid ibn Muaviyah l.a before I think of Yazeed ibne Ziad Mohasir e Kandi or Yazid ibn Maghful Jafi. It doesnt mean Naming your Kid Yazid is forbiden in my religion.
Same applies to Abu Bakar, Umar and Uthman....when someone mentions one of them my mind would go to Abu bakar bin qahafa or Umer bin Khatab or Uthman bin Afaan before it goes to Abu Bakar bin Hazim or Umar bin mukrin or Uthman bin Mavoon..... and even if did think of Abu Bakar bin Hazim or Umar bin mukrin or Uthman bin Mavoon.... I would still prefer names like Mohammed, Ali, Hassan, Hussain, Jafer, Musa, Raza, Naqi, Mahdi.*
Bro, why Ali R.A's mind didn't go to those personalities when he was naming his kids. The person who kills his unborn child doesn't come to his mind when naming his kids. You don't hold same standards for your Imam as for yourselves? This is strange.
Re: The family of Ali KaramAllaho Wajho at the battle of Karbala
The Imams were not petty people like we are, why is this so difficult for you to understand? I personally feel Shias should break away from this taboo of such names and should be open to naming their kids Umar, Uthman etc, but culture is culture.
Re: The family of Ali KaramAllaho Wajho at the battle of Karbala
............
He said no the minbar of Khilafat (4th)... Mansab of Imamat doesnt need any minbars..... His Job was to do what Prophet s.a.w did... Guide people to right path .... If Imam Zainulabideen a.s did as a captive in darbaar of Yazid then why would Imam Ali a.s need Minbar of Khilfat to do that ? .....
I don't know much about historical issues but If this is true, then could it resolve a lot of political issues between sunnis and shias? I suspect a lot of twists were added to Islamic history to suit the writers own perspectives and it takes a lot of research to dig out what actually happened.
Almost all of us are either Sunni or Shia because we were born to Sunni or Shia parents. When you grow up in such surroundings, I don't think discussions like this would ever be of much help. People are developing survival environments for a human society at Mars and we are stuck with naming conventions.
Re: The family of Ali KaramAllaho Wajho at the battle of Karbala
I don't know much about historical issues but If this is true, then could it resolve a lot of political issues between sunnis and shias? I suspect a lot of twists were added to Islamic history to suit the writers own perspectives and it takes a lot of research to dig out what actually happened.
Almost all of us are either Sunni or Shia because we were born to Sunni or Shia parents. When you grow up in such surroundings, I don't think discussions like this would ever be of much help. People are developing survival environments for a human society at Mars and we are stuck with naming conventions.
Its going to be an ugly reply becoz of typos... typing from phone sorry.....
I cudnt agree more.... if we really want guidence for someone.... online forums is not the place for it..... I would rather request smooth guy, ibne siddique and rest to pray 2 rakat nafal and pray that Allah guide me on right path..... and if they request I shall do the same in return..... this is a much better than spensing hours here and not have anyone agree with u even on a single issue.... so I try to stay away from these arguments but somehow manage to get myself here again and again......however I am seeing progress and I am not as active as I was.