The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Mashallah, great to see Sindhi’s are a big part of the growing middle class in Pakistan that has emerged in the Musharraf years. :jhanda:

http://thenews.jang.com.pk/daily_detail.asp?id=75271

The emerging Sindhi middle class

Tuesday, October 09, 2007

By Imtiaz Ali

Karachi

With changing economic conditions and opportunities, it can be seen that a new Sindhi middle class is emerging, which is gradually shedding feudal values and adopting more modern and urban characteristics.

Though the distorted pattern of political development in the country adversely affected development of the middle class in an organised form, it is likely that in the coming years, the role of the Sindhi middle class will undergo tremendous changes. They may gradually acquire the characteristics of a relatively refined urban class, say some observers. “Sindhi middle class is in a transitional form, which lacks sufficient resources but intends to adopt habits from the wealthier classes,” said Rauf Nizamani, a perceptive observer of Sindh. He said that there were two types of upper classes in Sindh. One represented feudal values, with their people mostly living in rural areas. The second type lives in cities, who have adopted a cosmopolitan culture and disregard their rural backgrounds.

The Sindhi middle class is facing a dilemma because of several different pressures. “The middle class lacks organisation due to feudal anarchy,” Nizamani said. Elaborating, he said that, “The class wants to adopt the cosmopolitan culture but it faces pressures from its feudal heritage as their families live in rural areas, embroiling them in confusion”.

He said that ‘particular Sindhi social characters’ represent this dilemma. However, with the passage of time, Sindhi middle class has come out of its ‘shell’ and some changes are discernable, Rauf Nizamani said.

He said that, firstly, the Sindhi middle class was increasingly integrating itself with other cultures and communities. Secondly, its social and political radicalisation had been subdued as it had developed a considerable stake in the Pakistani state. Thirdly, the “rationalisation of the situation” is increasing with pragmatic and professional attitudes.

He said that its one manifestation was the ‘flexibility’ shown by it for different ‘habits’. He said that the urban Sindhi middle class did not mull over peculiar traditions involving so-called honour, which still provokes strong reactions in certain parts of Sindh today. In extreme cases, middle class men have been found divorcing their wives or placing restrictions in extreme cases.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Its so sad that Sindhis are so marginalized in their own country to the point that people are surprised at the existance of a middle class sindhi group. There is a huge Sindhi urban population in Karachi. Aap kis planet pe reh rahe ho?

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

^ Planet India

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Nice to hear... Thanks.
Hopefully a rising middle class can do wonders for Sindh, perhaps even toppling the evils of feudalism.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Good to see Mr. Nizamani in the news. Very knowledgeable person.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Yep, that's what happened in Punjab, and inshallah it will finally break the wadera system in Sindh.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

It hasn't happened in all areas of the Punjab unfortunately. Sargodha and Jhang particularly have issues with feudalism. One can actually notice the stark contrast driving from Kallar Kahar up on the Potohar plateau down to Khushab in the plains and on to Sargodha.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.


How so ? The shackles of feudalism are being broken in "Urban" areas, not rural.

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

its good to see middle class is rising all over pakistan

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

as more of our population shifts to urban areas, feudalism's strangle hold will slowly erode...

and that will give rise to technocrats and an industrial economy

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

Well, most Sindhis have strong connections to the rural areas, considering most came from those rural areas...

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

M2K, that is true "in general". Karachi however is exception to that rule. This poor city is in the grip of "Urban feudals" (if you know what I mean).

Re: The emerging Sindhi middle class.

^^ Karachi reminds me of New York City in the 1860's

When the Irish immigrants came to New York in the 1840's-60's, the English and Dutch desendant New Yorkers hated their guts and wanted to kill them

Similar in Karachi

the MQM and Muhajir led by terrorist Altaf Hussain is akin to Bill the Butcher in Martin Scorcese's Gangs of New York