Re: The concept of being Stoned to Death
I fully agree with you…we should not close the doors of intellect…
but …
there are 4 pillars of islami shariah …
1.Quran
2.Hadees/sunnah
3.ijma
4.qiyyas
*** Ijmah **
*** Qiyaas**
***Ijtihaad **
comes only when there is not anthing mention in
*** quran**
*sunnah(shaheeh ahadees)
The supreme pillars of shariah and fiqah
but when in ahadees…clear cut negation of music…then no question of qiyaas..ijmah…and ijtihaad…
regarding music and musical instruments…
*hanafi
*shafi
*maliki
*hanabal
*ahle-hadees
*jaffria/shia
unanimously agreed …or Ijmah that it is forbidden…i dont know ..haram word can i use or not…but forbidden…
Only..Only..samah..means qawali…is llowed by few sufia..like chisti…etc…but under veryu strict conditions…
*** all have wadu**
no vulgarity at all
*** no cheapness*
etc etc
but a great no. of scholars also opposed that…Actually in indo-pak region..people used to music..so…this could lead people to islam…thats why..some people give that logic…
however…rest all is forbidden…only Daaf is allowed ..on wedding…battles..eid etc…
regarding ahadees..i quoted ..i purposely not given all stuff as it would have made the thread long…however i give the lnk below…so that ..on better understanding of ythis issue…we can reach…
http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=5000&ln=eng&txt=music
http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=11563&ln=eng&txt=music
http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=5011&ln=eng&txt=music
ruling on daff
http://www.islam-qa.com/index.php?ref=20406&ln=eng&txt=music