Re: The concept of being Stoned to Death
Yes...he is the earliest known source of compiled hadith. Did not occur in the same manner or time frame as the compilation of the Quran.
so...its means that he has collected fabricated ahadees...or made himself...what a blame on the great sahabi of prophet(pbuh) for which prophet(pbuh) himself prayed for knowledge of deen...and now ...you are questioning about the that pray of prophet(pbuh) !!!!!
[quote]
Collection is compilation, and I know there weren't only two. The point is, those efforts did not happen in paralelll with the compilation of the Quran.
[/quote]
so, what....even Abu bake like greatest sahabi was not willing to collect quran...it was Umar...who insisted him....similarly...i think....Umar also stopped people from quoting ahadees as in hadees...if someone will say lie to prophet(pbuh) will remain in hell...so its the atmost protection....but latter on...when sahabas...left the world....and and very less sahabs left...then people collected ahadees....so that to preserve that precious collection...in quran collection and latter period...people directly used to ask from sahabas...about particular saying...but latter...when sahabas were no more...its necessary to put ahadees just as quran...
[quote]
Not true, and the hadith themselves don't agree with that. Read my response to CG.
[/quote]
all narraotors are Ibne abbas...aisha..umar...abdullah ibne umar...abu huraira...ali...abu saeed khudri...jabir bin abdullah etc etc...are not they all sahabs ?????
tabai and taba tabi narrated them...as when sahabs died...its necesaary to protect ahadees ...so narration went on..whats so wrong with that ????