Re: The concept of being Stoned to Death
THats not the case, hadees were written down by many Sahabas. Abdullah bin Amr bin al-As for one, used to write down what he heard from his Master. Other Companions too put their collections of Hadith into writing later in life, particularly Abu Hurayrah and Abdullah b.Abbas, two very important sources of Hadith. So these are the same people who narrated us Quran and Hadees. As far as scale for the classifications of ahadees, it was not even needed at that time, since there was no corruption and when you scale a hadees, you only go up to the tabi and not a Sahabi. Classifications were created later on when some people tried to make up fake hadees, so the muhadithoon came up with the criteris to prevent that.
exactly....very beautiful...reply....
picoico..prophet(pbuh) himself sent the ahadees regarding the zakat and sadqa matters to the sana,Yemen..to Muaz bin Jabal...
*abu hurraira used to say that...although i remainedwith prohet(pbuh) but Abdullah bin amr bin al'as ha more ahadees memorized than me..because he used to write every hadees while i did not do that...i just memorized that....
*abu hurraira have written this ahadees to his student Hammam ...with name...i think..shaheefa sadiqa....
in the era of ummayyads and mostly in abbasids...due to historical tribal clash between ummayads and hashmises...which is the basi reason of shia sunni division...both parties fabricated ahadees to prove tier points....so then Muslim Bukhari ....raised and seperated the wrong one with pure one....it does not mean that 2 hijri muslims compiled ahadees...they just collected under different topics and subjects...some only collected the ahadees from one sahabi...etc etc..different ways of compiling books....but ahadees are actually transmitted as said by Conservative Girl...from the same sahabs which compiled quran.....