The Companions of the Cave and their Dog

[Muzna]

Re: The Companions of the Cave and their Dog

@vroom

its certainly mentioned in Books, my Imam mentioned at least one Scholar who described the actions of the dog, prior to arriving at the cave, he also mentioned the opinion the dog will be admitted as a person. Its not something she needs proof for, its a Mashur Matter . From what i know she would not need to explain the matter for you

I do not know if something personal is going on here behind the scenes, also the story is certainly not something to get angry about, so there is no need to chase the women and make her prove herself imposing upon her methodology that is itself suspect. I only see the ideology/methodology winning here, uff its like an isis invite to their methodology

I think the woman is with better ideology as she is, she is narrated from the works of the scholars, and she believes. MashAllah

Thanks for your opinion.
I’m not certain what you mean by “Mashur Matter” but if it has no other meaning than “popular matter” then I will, respectfully disagree with you.
I don’t believe that a belief that is “popular” but without any supporting corroboration should be propagated.

As for the rest of your post…regarding “something personal” or “something to get angry about”…I’m not sure what posts you are reading, or what you are trying to read between the lines so let me assure you, there is nothing there to read.