The Bystander Effect!

"The Bystander Effect: Why don’t we help others in emergencies?

In 1964, a woman named Kitty Genovese was brutally murdered outside her apartment. Although many surrounding neighbors had heard her cries and pleas for help, not one of them intervened to save her life. By the time someone called the police it was too late. Why did no one help this poor woman? Out of so many witnesses, how is it possible that it took so long for someone to pick up the phone and call for help?

The example above is a famous event illustrating the bystander effect, the idea that “the greater the number of bystanders who witness an emergency, the less likely any of them is to help the victim” (Aronson, Wilson & Akert, 2010, pg. 339). Two major factors influencing why people don’t help victims in an emergency are pluralistic ignorance and the diffusion of responsibility. Pluralistic ignorance is when in an ambiguous situation, people look to others before deciding whether or not to act. Many times, people will assume nothing is wrong because no one else acts, when in fact, something really is wrong; they misinterpret the situation. In the case of Kitty Genovese, for example, people may have figured everything was all right since no one seemed too concerned. The diffusion of responsibility says that as the number of bystanders increases, each bystander’s sense of responsibility to help decreases (Aronson, Wilson & Akert, 2010, pg. 341). Looking at the case of Kitty Genovese, since there were so many neighbors, people most likely had a decreased sense of individual responsibility, thinking that they didn’t need to help when there were so many others around that could help.

I can remember a time where I fell victim to the bystander effect. When you see a bad situation immediately jump into action to help or rescue a person and never wait for someone else to make the first move, a lot of people have lost their lives due to the “Bystander Effect”. In a given situation you are a part of bystander effect if you don’t make a move. You alone can break the effect by taking an action, always remember that tomorrow you or someone you love could be in that situation.

Overall, people really are influenced by others, especially when they are unsure of how to react to a given situation. When others are around, it affects the ways in which we act, and we usually fall prey to the bystander effect."

I found this on FB…

Has this ever happened to you guys? It has happened to me once…I still think about it…I still wonder if someone else called the police?


Restored attachments:

Re: The Bystander Effect!

This is very true. When you are alone and see someone in trouble you don't hesitate to help, however as soon as there are more people present.....somehow helping the other person doesn't seem like your responsibility.........like the author said "someone else will help If I don't"

I remember once I was driving on the freeway and saw a truck that had pulled over and his truck's bed was on fire. I instantly thought of calling 911 but then thought that there are so many cars passing by......someone else will surely call and never called.

Not the best relatable example, but I felt like it all relates to the same thought process people have.

Side note: Don't know if anyone watched the season finale episode of Arrow.....but it had a perfect example of this (Tommy's mother)

Interesting article and clearly there is a an unknown factor within us possibly a psychologically/mentally that devolves our responsibility.

Thankfully, I have always intervened regardless of how 'big' the crowd is and annoys the hell out of me someone who got there first didn't react.

Re: The Bystander Effect!

@Guac -I get what you said...

For me, it has happened both ways....

One was a gun shot somewhere close to where I lived...it was about 2am...I woke up..and looked out the window...saw nothing...then I saw some dude running...and a car came speeding up and asked him to get in...but he did not...and the car turned around went somewhere....coz I didn't see exactly what happened...if this guy was connected or which direction the gun shot came from...I didn't call the police....also coz I know there are always so many ppl around that area....

Another one was...a guy was totally drunk, it was raining like crazy..again 2am, he could not take one step without falling all over...his friends just left him there...he kept trying to walk...and he was wearing all black and he kept falling on to the main road....the third time he fell on to the road..it was smack in the middle...I decided it was time to call 911 before he got run over by some car...he managed to crawl onto the side walk..and just sat there...I felt sorry for him too...

They came and took him away...

Re: The Bystander Effect!

That's why....i think....it's suggested to yell "Fire" instead if "help" in emergencies because people are afraid to get involved if it's the latter.

Re: The Bystander Effect!

Off topic. So apologies in advance.

Reading the title, Mr. Kamran Akmal came to mind. Standing by while conceding byes.

Re: The Bystander Effect!

Or one should address/approach people personally, so that there is no room left for diffusion of responsibility or pluralistic ignorance. In that case people will feel responsibe to help because the victim approached them specifically.