Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
Ok you lots are declaring shias kafir..................what next.
A shia who prays 5 times a day is much better than those who don't pray regularly or don't pray at all.
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
shia's dont pray 5 times a day though
prophet SAW taught us to pray 5 times a day!
they miss their asr or maghrib.. cant rmbr which one.. but i know they pray like only 3 times a day... so whats that all about ??
in islam a muslim must pray 5 times a day and if someone abonds his 5 prayers.. consensus among the sahabah's was that this person becomes apostate
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
Your ignorance has lead your humilation once again. Shias dont miss their asr or maghrib prayers rather they combine it with Zuhur and Isha prayers respectively and if this is unilsamic to you then i will not be surprised if you throw your edict fo Kufr here as well:
Sahih Muslim **Book 004, Number 1515:
Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) observed the noon and afternoon prayers together, and the sunset and Isha' prayers together without being in a state of fear or in a state of journey.
Sahih Muslim *Book 004, Number 1516: *
Ibn 'Abbas reported: The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) observed the noon and afternoon prayers together in Medina without being in a state of fear or in a state of journey. (Abu Zubair said: I asked Sa'id [one of the narrators] why he did that. He said: I asked Ibn 'Abbas as you have asked me, and he replied that he [the Holy Prophet] wanted that no one among his Ummah should be put to [unnecessary] hardship.)
And many more... !
Having said that, according to Shia Fqiha, one can pray Zuhur Asar and Maghrib Isha seperately, but there is no harm if they combine it as well.
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
yeah but he didnt do it all the time now did he?
thanks for the hadiths and thanks for keeping it brief (Y)
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
the sahabah's didnt pray like that everyday and they didnt pray with the prophet SAW like that everyday
soo why do the shia's pray like that everyday?
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
its better to pray instead of not praying at all .....anyway i've heard that in shia's books it does'nt say anywhere that they should pray **always **combined.
they do it on thier own.
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
the sahabah's didnt pray like that everyday and they didnt pray with the prophet SAW like that everyday soo why do the shia's pray like that everyday?
If they pray everyday like this or not, the main thing is the permissibility, like what you were few posts back accusing Shias of missing Asr and Maghrib prayers, so its not that, rather one is allowed to pray like this any time he wants (according to the above traditions). And thats why there is a seperate chapter in Sahih Muslim for "Combining prayers". So its noy about whether they prayed single day like that or more than that, the main thing is permissibility.
Having said that, there are Shias who pray seperately as well. So thats not an issue.
Re: THE BEST THREE GENERATIONS
The tabhlighi jamaat is NOT a madhab sister. I think you have it confused a little.
It is just a movement, nothing wrong about it. We have different organizations such as charity, muslim associations..etc nothing wrong about them right?
Same way the tablighi jamaa is just a movement where we learn about deen.
they are the people who follow the sunnah if you look around and actually stay with them you will see them every act is sunnah.. world renouned scholars say that this movement is the best in this era.. thru it many people reverted to Islam.
While on jamaa we read the hadiths, quran, talk about the sunnah, we listen to talks which include stories from hadiths and quran.. mashallah it's incredible.
plus, you don't pay anything for food or shelter because the masjid is providing you with everything.
It is not the so called "FBI undercover jamaa" or some "British secret agency", when i hear those i laugh at them!
The women are allowed to pray in the masjids, I don't know where you get the misconception of women not allowed..
You see, in our pak-indo culture, we have this backward mentality, that women can't be seen in a masjid or in malls uncovered..etc..
Women are allowed to pray in the masjid as long ofcourse there is no intermingling and they are covered. OBVIOUS.
I hope that helped you a bit.
Here is my list of sites that I visit often!
www.askimam.org - Mufti Ebrahi Desai (QA)
www.sunnipath.com - Great Info site with QA
www.sunniforum.com - A forum for Sunnis LOTS OF INFO sign up!
www.islamrocks.com - Info books, lectures, lots of links.
www.daruliftaa.com - Info/QA
www.shariahprogram.ca
www.saleel.com
www.tafsir.com
www.beconvinced.com
www.eat-halal.com
www.edars.com - Collection of Lectures (MUST VISIT!)
www.tasawwuf.org