"Tendulkar not world's best" - Gavaskar

**Tendulkar not world’s best **

NEW DELHI, June 22: India’s cricket legend Sunil Gavaskar said Friday that Australia’s Steve Waugh was a better Test batsman than Sachin Tendulkar for his ability to deliver in tight situations.

Gavaskar, writing in his widely syndicated column, slammed Tendulkar for throwing away his wicket in the second Test against Zimbabwe at Harare this week, which the hosts won by four wickets to square the two-match series.

Tendulkar slashed a widish delivery to point after making 69 as India collapsed from 197 for three to 234 all out, leaving Zimbabwe a modest victory target of 157. “It’s time to listen to the Australians who rate their captain as the best Test batsman in the world for his ability to either win or save matches for his team outside his home environs,” Gavaskar wrote.

Tendulkar was the mainstay as India chased their first series win outside the sub-continent in 15 years after winning the first Test at Bulawayo. But brittle batting by an outstanding line-up - at least on paper - ruined India’s hopes at Harare after scoring 237 in the first innings and 234 in the second. “It was the batting that let the team down,” wrote Gavaskar, the first batsman to complete 10,000 Test runs and the scorer of a record 34 centuries.

"When batsmen who are set, have done all the hard work, throw their wickets away to loose shots, then the team is never going to put enough runs on the board. “Why blame Venkatsai Laxman when the best batsman in the universe (Tendulkar) gets a half-century and then gets out, when a big score from him is the crying need of the team.” This was, however, not the first time Tendulkar had disappointed his fans. Tendulkar could score just four runs when India, chasing 120 to win, were bowled out for 81 by the West Indies in the Barbados Test in 1997. Against Pakistan at Madras in 1999, Tendulkar failed to complete the job despite scoring 136 as India succumbed by 12 runs.

In contrast, Steve Waugh has the reputation of producing runs when it matters most. His 110 against India in the second Test at Calcutta early this year came after his team slid to 269 for eight in the first innings. Brian Lara of the West Indies and Pakistan’s Inzamam-ul-Haq are the other batsmen renowned for playing match-winning knocks under pressure.

Australia were at the receiving end when Lara scored a robust unbeaten 153 to mastermind his team’s one-wicket victory at Bridgetown in 1998-99. Inzamam, rated by his Pakistani colleagues as the best batsman in the world, made a brilliant 114 to set up his team’s series-levelling win against England at Old Trafford earlier this month.-AFP

Source Here

Depends on what factors you think make a batsman great.
If it is technical soundness and statistics, Tendulkar leads the pack. But if it means ability to play crucial and decisive innings for the team, Waugh is better than Tendulkar any day.Countless times has Steve Waugh taken his team out of the woods and to victory. Tendulkar,on the other hand, may have scored centuries by the heap but he has often shown a tendency to get himself out when it matters most. The most vivid memory that I have is of the Madras Test between India and Pak which India lost by a mere 12 runs. Only if Tendulkar ,after being on the wicket for so long, had not played that stupid shot to get himself out when India were close to the target , Indian team would have romped home easily.There have been several other instances where Tendulkar has gifted his wicket in a way which has prompted many to say that he sometimes just seems to get bored with batting, which ceases to be challenging for him after a point of time.
On the other hand Steve Waugh is all about having a sound temperament and an ice-cool attitude that more than makes up for what he lacks in technique.He wasn't even a specialist batsman when he broke into the international scene - he was also a regular bowler - and that is what makes his batting performances in recent times so much more spectacular.

[This message has been edited by Old Monk (edited June 23, 2001).]

Agree with Old Monk, Technically Tendulkar is the best in the world. However when it comes to playing crucial innings for India he has let the team down.

Surely the mark of a great thoguh, is someone who has outstanding technical ability but more importantly the ability to deliver in tight situations.

Great sportsmen are those who can deliver surely? Consider Miandad and a certain Sharjah match....