Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Dhoni all set to become Captain.

Do we have any other choices? Kumble? Zheer? or GANGULY?


Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Cricinfo staff

November 6, 2007

Sachin Tendulkar has declined the Indian Test captaincy, citing personal reasons, two days before the national selectors are scheduled to decide on the position. The Board of Control for Cricket in India confirmed that Tendulkar turned down the offer as he felt a younger captain would be better.

“Sachin Tendulkar has conveyed to Sharad Pawar [BCCI president] that he was not in a position to accept the captaincy of the Indian team for the Tests,” Niranjan Shah, the board secretary, said in a statement. “He [Tendulkar] was of the view that presently the Indian team was doing extremely well and the Board must think of appointing a younger person as the captain, looking at the future of the team.”

The board also clarified that Tendulkar didn’t reject the captaincy as a mark of protest, especially after the dropping of seniors like Rahul Dravid. “We wish to clarify that Sachin has not written any letter nor has he expressed anguish about anything as is being projected in the media.”

Tendulkar, 34, was widely tipped to be named as India’s Test captain - he was vice-captain during the Test series in Bangladesh and England - after Rahul Dravid resigned in September. “I don’t feel right about it at the moment,” Tendulkar told CNN-IBN, an Indian news channel, after it was earlier learnt that he had spoken to members of the board.

The Telegraph, the Kolkata-based daily, quoted an unnamed source as saying the selectors are set to hand the captaincy to Mahendra Singh Dhoni, who has played 20 Tests. “My understanding is that Sachin is not keen and has made that known to some people,” he said. “So Dhoni looks the favourite. It’s a plus that he is already the one-day and Twenty20 captain.”

However, Greg Chappell, who quit as India’s coach in April, said Dhoni may be too inexperienced for the Test captaincy. “He [Dhoni] is doing his apprenticeship in the limited-over forms of the game,” Chappell told the news channel Times Now. “Probably another 12 months or more I think before he is perhaps ready for all three of them. A tour of Australia behind him will finish him off nicely as a cricketer and as a potential leader.”

Ravi Shastri, who was India’s manager in Bangladesh earlier this year, felt that handling the Test captaincy to Dhoni would burden him. “It will put him under a lot of pressure. In future he may do it but not at this moment,” he told PTI. “He has a lot of talent but I think he is not ready for this responsibility now.”

Shastri also advocated having separate captains for the Test and ODI teams. As for India’s coach, he said it would not be wise to rush the process. “There is no need to rush things to get a coach. We need to pick the ideal person. We just can’t take anybody and make him the coach. And the team is winning, so why the tension? We’ll wait for the right time and the right man for the job.”

The selectors are due to meet at Mohali on November 8 to announce the team for subsequent one-day internationals in the current series against Pakistan, and pick a Test captain.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Kumble should be the Test Captain. The guy gives it his all and should be rewarded for his good work for so many years.

Also, since Kumble is not an ODI player anymore, there are no chances of any potential ego clashes with Dhoni.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Dhoni looks like to be the one who should lead India on long term basis however I agree that it's a bit too quick for him. So basically India needs a short term captain who can train Dhoni to be a long term captain.

Tendi doesn't want this role so Kumble should be the one next in line to get this role.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

I would like to see Dhoni's performace overseas for an extended time before handing him over the Captaincy.

While his wicket-keeping has been top class...his batting style/technique still makes me uneasy about his long-term future as a Test batsman (esp on sporting pitches).

The above said, the selectors are most likely going to make him the Test Captain anyway.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Bring back Shastri.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

^Posting Under the Influence (PUI) Alert !!

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

kumble for sure
in his interviews, it seems like he wants it bad and definitely deserves it

i think shastri is right about dhoni, he will accept all responsibilites but probably not a good idea to dump so much on him in such a short span of time, he might feel he can handle it, but i think its too much too soon

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Yeah I agree Kumble would be a very good choice in the short-term. He deserves it for the hard work he has put in over so many years (17 to be precise). No bowler in history has won India more Test matches than Anil Kumble and he now has a test century (Oval 2007) to his name as well, so he can also bat a bit. His test tally (566 wkts) puts him at no.3 on the all-time list, behind only Shane Warne and Muttiah Muralitharan emphasising his great contribution to Indian cricket

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Selectors have difficult decision to make Indian captaan. I think Kumble is good for India captaan, also ganguly

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Dhoni might look good in few games but i doubt he has what it takes to be good captain even in one day. He is good for 20/20.

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

If they (selectors) offered it to TENDULKAR it means that they were not opting for fresh blood so now when making DHONI captain, they will not (and should not) give this as a reason.

Now if they were looking for "Seniority" or "Experience", Kumble fits the outfit.

and if they were only trying to throw the blanket off them, stay tuned for some more comedy !

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

i would have to disagree
i think he looks solid, and i think leadership comes to naturally to him

Re: Tendulkar declines Test captaincy

Can Tendulkar for once do something for his country and put his personal benefits aside? Why is he so pussy scared of captaining Team India? Because it would affect his individual records? Fk it man who cares about your 20,000 runs and 100 centuries, just play for the team when they need you. They have to now assign that weazle Kumble as the skipper. The guy is too emotional to lead.