Talibans lashing girl Dr.Asrar View

re: Talibans lashing girl Dr.Asrar View

I am saddened by the lack of intellectual depth displayed by people promoting Taliban Islam. Please read history with unbiased views. There have been a lot of movements like Taliban in Islamic History that have done terrible things in the name of Islam and Quran.

Please read who khawrijis were. Before you start hurling shia/sunni insults, read the descriptions with an open mind. They believed and clearly stated they were doing it in the name of Allah. They were such devout readers of Quran that when Muslims approached their encampment they heard buzzing of bees from a distance and on getting to the camp they realized that over 5,000 were reciting Quran.

Please do not be misled by these preachers of hatred. Look at the way Islam was during the time of the Prophet (SAW), how he was kind and forgiving and how punishments were administered. The true Sunnah is the Sunnah of the Prophet (SAW) alone and there is no one absolutely no one who can claim to leave a sunnah to be followed except him (SAW).

Prophet (SAW) told us to follow two things after him that will stop us from leading astray Quran and my Sunnah , not the Sunnah of Sheikhan or Umayads or anyone else. He (SAW) is the last messenger and brought something to this world, no one can add or substract to it.

My appeal to all muslims is to look at how the Prophet (SAW) conducted himself. How many people were found hanging dead in the trees in city centers/markets, how he treated women, what were his views on education for all Muslims. How he treated those raised their voices against him in his presence and those who disagreed, on how many muslims he pronounced takfir and then let that be the criteria that you judge these so called champions of Islam.

re: Talibans lashing girl Dr.Asrar View

first of all no one from area belong to such vedio claim that this is authentic vedio, nor any government official do such thing, so, before blamming taliban we have to discuss about vedio authenticity.

also many of us watched vedio tv one in programme of Mr. Mubasshir Luqman and this vedio was authentic where police killed 18-20 years boy in fake police mukabila. no body from so called moderator from pakistan and ngo condemn such act of police and even no body arrest thouse police officer who act this.

re: Talibans lashing girl Dr.Asrar View

As-Salamu 'Alaykum

I’m not surprised to read the modernists comments as they’re always raping sharee’ah. However, Dr. Israr made a mistakes and let me remind everyone again that he’s not hujjah for orthodox Muslims.

In video three he said that the tareeka of taliban was correct, which is not right. Making the person lie down is a minoirty’s incorrect opinion. I guess maybe Dr. Israr was talking about punishing the girl in public.

The interviewer showed a lack of common sense regarding 911 & Osama’s videos.

@desert bird

why are you trying to beat around the bush and displaying your hatred towards othrodx Muslims? When did Dr. Israr said anything which you smoked in your post#4](http://www.paklinks.com/gs/6447863-post4.html)?