Re: Taliban cut off heads of 17 people for having music at party 
story has turned into lets bash islam thread by i presume secularists.
Another words, if there are people bashing Islam, they must be “secularists.” How did I miss read that?
I dont think anyone has declared themselves to be “secular” on this thread.
Well, a blaming anyone of being a serial killer, despite not having proven it in a court of law, would still be an injustice. But for the sake of argument lets assume he has admited to killing men as the Taliban have. Suddenly, women start dying. The murder has all the hallmarks of the serial killer in question, however he doesnt admit it.
Now, its reasonable to conclude that the serial killer, being as deranged as he is he, may also be a liar. Its nor unheard of that serial killers be liars aswell. So believing the serial killer is infact the same person killing women is not an unreasonable conclusion, and you would not fault the police for following this line of reasoning either.
In the case of the Taliban, there is a known history of such criminality. They are known to be tactical, manipulative. There is no valid reason to conclude they didnt do it, and every reason to assume they did.