Taliban cut off heads of 17 people for having music at party :-(

Med911 · October 10, 2012, 4:35am

Re: Taliban cut off heads of 17 people for having music at party

Then if they stay silent about it and no one knows about it, then their act has not harmed society. If they are truly repentant then Allah (SWT) is GafooruRaheem. But if “taking his or her chances” defines them then that is what defines faithlessness too … There is absolutely nothing the law is allowed to do to a criminal without evidence or confession.

The truly repentant will seek the forgiveness of God, and fear the punishment and constantly be asking for forgiveness in this life, not hedging bets with God. On the other hand … I’m not sure what is better … To remain silent for the sake of reducing Fassad or to make a disclosure to be cleansed … I guess this would depend on the case at hand. Remaining silent is what I would recommend … Let them come to peace with their act. But if they can’t come to peace with it … Then they drive themselves to such confessions …which then become public matters and must be dealt with appropriately according to hudd for there is no doubt in the matter of a repeated proven confession and the real threat needs to be there.

And what if there are witnesses, and it is proven, should they be punished with death then?

By the way, getting back to the Taliban, after the attack on Malala Yusufzai today, are you still on the wall about wether those scum are actually criminals or misunderstood mujahids? Or are you among those who try to make a distinction between the Pakistan based ones and the Afghn ones?