Taliban attacking Shi'a kids in Pakistan

AFP: Gunmen ambush Pakistan school minibus: police

I guess they must have taken a cue from their late hero Shamil Basayev when he took a school hostage and slaughtered 186 children in Beslan, Russia.

Comments?

Re: Taliban attacking Shi'a kids in Pakistan

sick people !

The children were killed by Russians forces storming the school. Though is very condemnable to take school kids hostage, the Russians did lot worse crimes against Chechans.

In case you haven't noticed, 95% of their victims are sunni

They attack everybody, so this is a non-issue

An excellent point. :k:

These non muslims certainly do kill sunnis, but they seem to take excessive liking to killing shias more then any others. They have been doing exclusively horrible things to these people for the last few years. If you read the reports from parachanaar, or keep up with them, its nauseating: cutting off hands and other limbs of shia children and young men.

Well, what i would advise my shia brothers is; " In order to to avoid such reaction they must rethink of their swearing of sahaba. I know that Talibans go to extreme extents but again shias are equally responsible . "

If i were a shia…i would definately stop swearing and make peace with talibans and would tell them that i am a good guy and i dont swear sahaba anymore , so please dont attack my kids.

Yes, clearly these children are as equally responsible as the grown men who killed them :rolleyes:

I wouldn’t say that but the thing is that shia parents should not teach their kids to swear and say bad things about beloved personalities of muslims.

I remember when i was a school kid we had this shia kid and he said that when he grow up he would kill " Hazrat Omer razi Aa Taalaa " Noazbillah. I told my dad about it…and my dad told me that shias teach their kids such things.

So, i guess its their parents who teach them such stuff. Anyways as I said both parties are responsible for this tragedy. Inorder to avoid such things in the future a careful examination of deeds is required.

Re: Taliban attacking Shi'a kids in Pakistan

No religion culture or society promotes killing of innocent children
those who do it can have any motive - but religion

Re: Taliban attacking Shi'a kids in Pakistan

The title of the thread is misleading. There is no mention of Taliban doing it.

Anyways, who ever did this is not Taliban (student), nor a muslim and for me not even a human being. Lets pray and hope for improvement in the situation in Pakistan.

BR this is just sick. Since when did you make a law that anyone saying a bad thing in their house (and not in public) about one sahabi or the other is a punishable by death?

Huh? Tell us if Sahabas themselves didn't say bad things against each other.

Then show us where in Islamic teachings Sunnis should murder Shias because someone somewhere hidden in hujra said something about a sahabi.

Are you high on something?

Even Ayatullahs (and they were never my favorite) do not go on loudspeaker and say anything bad against sahabis.

So how dare you come up with this sick post?

Taliban murderers are sick, and their supporters and sympathizers are even sicker.

Re: Taliban attacking Shi’a kids in Pakistan

Bitter Reality shows the type of poison that makes Sipah-e-Sahaba and Lashkar-e-Jhangvi terrorists teach kids to blow themselves up in sectarian murders.

Note how easily this terrorist lover Bitter Reality justifies barbaric murder!

“Both parties are wrong” :rolleyes::grumpy::mad:

In other words, the victim is just as much to blame as a psychopathic bigoted group who kills people for belonging to the “wrong” sect.

To terrorist supporting bigots like “Bitter Reality”, their hatred of other sects is more than the love of humanity. It is these type of people who allow SSP/LeJ killers to escape and live among the populace. For “Bitter Reality”, Azam Tariq and Riaz Basra were justified in their actions because the Shias “insult” the Sahaba.

“Ae bhai, how can they not slaughter those guys for insulting Sahabis. SSP may be wrong, but Shias “provoke” them by insulting Sahaba”

What logic is this?

Hitler used the same logic to kill Jews. Narindar Modi and BJP use the same logic to kill Muslims in India. Israelis use the same logic to slaughter Palestinians.

This is the mindset of terrorism. Laanat hae…

Indeed!

So that makes it okay for terrorists to take children hostage? :rolleyes:

And no, there were first-hand accounts of brutality by the terrorists when the school was under siege.

Only Muslims make excuses for brutal crimes by other Muslims :rolleyes:

Some convuluted logic this :mad:

Well leme explain...

Actually we have to see the cause instead of the crime.....

Say that A swears at B...and B kills A......

now u have to chose between the following answers and try to cover what actually happened

1. B killed A

2. A killed B

3. B killed A after A sweared at B

A healthy mind will opt for answer 3....caz its more complete and has the backgrounder.

This is what i meant.....I condemn the killing but at the same time the shia must understand that swearing at Sahaba has risks.

If the fanatics anti-Islam elements were only targeting shias than your logic may have been understandable. But they kill ANYONE who disagrees with them in ANYWAY.
How will you justify those killings?

It is obvious that these fitna-mongers will kill shias/other-minorities/anyone-who-disagrees-with-their-brand-of-Islam no matter WHAT.

If the fanatics anti-Islam elements were only targeting shias than your logic may have been understandable. But they kill ANYONE who disagrees with them in ANYWAY. For example, killing of Sunni Tehreek leaders in Karachi.
How will you justify those killings?

It is obvious that these fitna-mongers will kill shias/other-minorities/anyone-who-disagrees-with-their-brand-of-Islam no matter WHAT.

These anti-Islam terrorists are a threat to Pakistan and its security, and cause bad name to Islam everywhere.

Killing anybody who disagrees with you is definately wong but you failed to see the logic of what i said leme provide you another example :

Say** "I - a Muslim is living in a highly conservative christian society for instance in South America , Mexico or the bible belt of USA now..........disagreeing with them is one thing and swearing at Jesus and Paul would be another"**

Now, if i am dumb...and I don't do risk anaylsis... ...and start insulting Jesus and Catholic saints.....the chances are that i will get a kick on my ** S.**

PS : Disagreeing and insulting /cursing/swearing are different!

I hope this example has cleared the confusion

Thanks