**Tafseer Tabri **
Re: tafseer Tabri
Abb yea app read kare aur faizyaad hoo.agar app yea kisi ko batain tu woh sirf hasay ga lakin yea aisi riwayaat humhare tafaseer main shamil hoo gaye jis ko parh kar app kia soochain gaye.
deeni aur mazhabi wakayaat aur ek paighambar ki zindagi ka khaaka jis taqaddas aur paakeezgi ko chahta hai uss ke saath iss bay-hooda aur sooqiyana qissay ka kya joar ho sakta hai,ye sab israelki kharafaat hain. Bud Deen aur mulhid yahoodiyun ne islami rawayaat ko maskhara pun aur istehza ka shikaar bananay ke liye ye qissay gharh k islami rawayaton mein shaamil kar diye. Jab ehle kitab islam laaye to unhon ne inn qisson ko bayaan kya aur iss tarha wo hamari tafseeron mein jaga paa gaye......
Re: Yafseer Tabri
the author clearly mentions that these are "ghareeb" incidents, which means that scholars recognize them as 'unauthentic and weird'....
they r added in tafasir so that when u read a verse, u can also be told of unauthentic material/stories associated with that particular verse....
but if u read them out of context, and bring just two papers out of thousands of them in a tafseer, u will always find them as stupid....
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Thats all based on ancient jewish mythology that corrupted old testament (specially The Genesis is full of these stories).
Many scholars and theologians of Iraq, Syria and Egypt of medival times also studied Bible and other books that influenced some of them. That was the time when these kinds of concepts entered into Islamic books. Qassasul Anbiya is the biggest example in modern times.
Re: Yafseer Tabri
but if u read them out of context, and bring just two papers out of thousands of them in a tafseer, u will always find them as stupid....
Hve u read All Tafaseer.they mention hadees like this at the end they say they r "Ghareeb".App ke zindagaye khataam hoo jaye gaye lakin yea Tafaseer Khataam nahi hoo gayeen
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Ab Hum Tafseer Tabri mein Hazrat Suleman(AS) ke wakaya ka haal bayaan kertay hain,
Ek ayat hai jis mein Malika Saba ke baaray mein hai ke wo Hazrat Suleman(AS) ke Mehal mein ayi to sehan ko dekh ke samjhi ke ye paani hai aur usne pounchay ooper charha liye…
hai…
Iss ayat ki tafseer , Janab Tabri sahib ne ye ki 
Re: Yafseer Tabri
I think you meant TAFAASEER… lagtaa hai aap naY paRhaa hai.. aap kee tau zindagi hee khatam ho gaYee ho gee 
Re: Yafseer Tabri
Main tamam tasaveer ke baat kar raha tha ek ke nahi app nay shayad theek se nahi parha.wase yea haal hoota hai riwayata ke ainay main.parhaye aur apna sir phoortay jayee
Re: Yafseer Tabri
please speak a language that we can understand… half of the time, it makes me understand the words if you said paRhiye or paRhaaiye … 
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Allah ahs bestwoed us with Aqal, and ability to do some research, Muslims can find out which Riwayaat are true and whihc are false. Does not mean that one has to abandon all Tafaseer completely. Tafaseer are "opinions" and not Kalaamullah. But i knwo where u r coming from and i am afraid that people in ur camp make equally stupid "tafsir". Some say there are only two prayers bcoz only two are mentioned in Quran, others say there is no ritual prayer at all.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
^
the mufasir clearly tells u what riwayat is ghareeb, and what is saheeh, if one doesnt have 'aqal' to differentiate between the two when the mufasir has clearly mentioned it, i dont think he/she can actually do research on anything....
Re: Tafseer Tabri
So where should we use our akaal to accept or reject HAdees and our research should be only in our 1 circle which all move around to See who's the shih ravi and riwayaat.u r right they r not KALAAMALLAH.U know na where i come from Tell me Shouldnt i tadaboor on quran.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Ofcourse you should do tadabbur on Quran, but, what you are posting here is NOT tadabbur on Quran. You are just telling people to abandon Tafaseer. If you want to do Tadabbur do it by all means. Let us know what you think about any verse rather than trying to negate someone else. Be positive in your approah.
Re: Yafseer Tabri
but if u read them out of context, and bring just two papers out of thousands of them in a tafseer, u will always find them as stupid....
And this is the same as what the non-believers do when they quote from out of context verses in the Quran and say that the Quran teaches to kill all non-believers period...
LOLZ...
ImranJaff ---Tafseer Tabari is by someone who was much more well versed in arabic and its meanings then you or any other Quranist..
Re: Tafseer Tabri
yes and they do the same for many other things. In the end their group (pervaizy or others) are just completely abandoning the deen. Creating complete chaos among them. They can only raise questions such as these but have no answers to any of the practical issues of deen.
And practical issues are not important to them because they are followers of whims and desires. They don't care about practical problems because they think they are not required.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
You are right ICO..but another issue is that Tadabbur (pondering) requires a guided intellect...not an intellect that is misguided by darkness.
If someone puposely wants to shut the light off and still try to read, its only their wisdom (or lack of) that can be blamed.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
too bad i cant read urdu ....... :(
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Infect I think its good for you.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
Br. Jaff do you believe Hazrat Essa's miracle? I red somewhere that he had powers through it he gave life to dead men of course with the will of Allah Subah ho tala but he showed that miracle many times.
Re: Tafseer Tabri
*Has anyone read the last sentence of the 2nd PAGE. That expalins it all. *