Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

Was this ever in doubt?

Who was naive enough to think that you can negotiate with these animals?

When will Pakistan learn. They tried in 2001, 2003, 2006 and 2008 and all of them fell apart.

There is no option to deal with these people but to use overwhelming force to defeat them.

I hope this message gets through to the Army Brass

DAWN.COM | + Pakistan | Sufi Mohammed calls off Swat peace deal

SWAT: The chief of outlawed Tehreek e Nifaz e Shariat Mohammedi has withdrawn from the peace deal with the government and has said all peace camps in the region will be abolished, DawnNews has reported.

Mohammed, who brokered the peace deal between the Taliban and the government of Pakistan has claimed that the authorities have used delaying tactics in imposing the Nizam-i-Adal (Islamic courts) in the Swat region.

The announcement casts serious doubt on the durability of a cease-fire in the Swat valley that U.S. officials worry will create another sanctuary for allies of al-Qaida responsible for a rising tide of violence in the nuclear-armed country.

Imposing Islamic law in Swat, a one-time tourist haven, was the key plank of an accord worked out in February between the provincial government and Sufi Muhammad, a cleric who once led thousands of volunteers to fight U.S. forces in Afghanistan but has since renounced violence.

Thanks in part to Muhammad’s mediation, the agreement ended 18 months of terror and bloody clashes that had left hundreds dead and forced up to one-third of the previously prosperous valley’s 1.5 million residents to flee.

But the militants have retained their arms and this week pushed into a neighboring area where they fought deadly gunbattles with villagers and police.

President Asif Ali Zardari has said he will only sign an order introducing Islamic law in the region once peace has been restored _ without saying how that would be determined.

Muhammad, who had been camped out in the valley’s main town of Mingora with hundreds of black-turbaned supporters, said they were leaving to protest Zardari’s ‘negative attitude.’

'From now on, President Zardari will be responsible for any situation in Swat, ‘ the white-bearded cleric told reporters. ‘The provincial government is sincere and our agreement with the provincial government is intact, but we are ending our peace camp.’

Television footage showed dozens of Muhammad’s supporters crammed into a column of cars and driving out of Mingora, some of them clutching black and white flags.

Mian Iftikhar Hussain, the information minister for the government of North West Frontier Province, said he believed the federal government was ‘sincere’ in supporting the peace effort, but said he couldn’t say when the Islamic law bill would be signed.

‘We are committed to bringing about a durable peace and we will continue our efforts in the changed situation,’ Hussain said.

Zardari aides said officials were looking into the matter but gave no further comment.

Hasan Askari Rizvi, a political and military analyst, said Zardari may have delayed signing off on the agreement because of concerns within the year-old civilian government over negotiating with militants.

‘The opinion is divided,’ Rizvi said. ‘A good number of people in the government think that this is not the right approach.’

Zardari’s foot-dragging also lets him save face with Western critics of the deal, he said.

Under former military ruler Pervez Musharraf, Pakistan struck a series of peace deals with militants along the Afghan border that U.S. officials say let the Taliban and al-Qaida regroup and focus their energy on attacking American and NATO troops in Afghanistan.

President Barack Obama has made a sharp increase in financial aid to Pakistan conditional on it demonstrating more commitment to rooting out al-Qaida and other extremist groups.

U.S. envoy Richard Holbrooke said Tuesday after meeting Zardari in Islamabad that the situation in Swat had helped persuade more of Pakistan’s political elite of the need to combat extremism at America’s side.

Pakistan desperately needs economic aid to ease the fallout from an economic crunch. It also faces an exodus of foreign investors in the face of rising violence and political uncertainty.

On Thursday, one policeman died and five more were injured as protests erupted across the southwestern province of Baluchistan after the discovery of the mutilated bodies of three missing political activists.

The trio included the leader of one of an array of Baluch groups campaigning _ or fighting _ for more autonomy and control over natural resources in the impoverished province, which borders Afghanistan and Iran.

Activists immediately blamed Pakistan’s spy agencies for the political activists’ deaths. Police said they were investigating.

Over the weekend, a previously unknown Baluch group freed an American U.N. worker after holding him for two months to press the government to release political prisoners.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

So if Americans say they should talk to the less hard line elements of Taliban thats just good sense but Pakistan cannot do that or is that by definition a Taliban is hardliner if he talks to Pakistan but moderate if he talks to US. Come on man how can you not see whats going on.........

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

Let's try unconditional surrender next.

saroo, american policy of moderate taliban is also a failure.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

Gadhari sold his soul to the US. He should have enforced Nizam-a-adal by now. There's nothing wrong with that unless you only want to do what pleases the US.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

^ why cant they get their nizam-e-adl through democratic means? win the elections in their region, introduce local laws.

They cant. Thus they shouldnt be allowed it.

Niza-e-Adal hahahha.,

You mean lashing of girls by dimwit Mullahs. Wha bhai wah.

Adal means Mullah's danda and innocent's @rse. If that is Adal, please leave us "bay-Adal". OK?

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

I don't know why, but I'm not sad about Swat peace deal falling apart. It was going to happen & anyone who has been paying attention should know terrorists use these so called peace deals to regroup and fight again. I really hope that army moves to clean up the area b/c these people are serious threat to Pakistan's existence now.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

You're only focusing on what happened before this deal was reached. They didn't even give it a chance. Traitors got what they really wanted.

Lies again. Islamists love to lie about the true conditions under Talibans draconian rule.

Summun bukmun. Sadly.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

Sufi should get the same treatment that Lal Masjid mullah receieved. Thats the only solution.
That would satisfy him as well. This world is not perfect for him, may be he should try the other one.


Yeah, secular extremists are the beacon of truth, everyone else is a lier. summun bukmun ummun, look who is talking...

secular extremists? what is that?
are there secular people killing people in the name of secularism?
name one?

Why the heck w bring secular religious thing in between debate, why not put our energies to debate and discuss strategically.
I didnt like this deal as well i mean who is this mullah sufi, but supported it as a move to remove any doubts that goal is nizam e adl zardari should hve sgned the ordinance with life of 3 months, and asking mullah to ak taliban to surrender their weapons a agreed.
Knowing that they wont agree deal is off, operation on people on your back.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

The only secualar extremists i can think of are the MQM which is nothing but a mafia organization....

but religious extremists have killed thousands of pakistanis in brutal attacks and made pakistan the most dangerous country on the planet

destroying foreign investment, sporting events, and defacting the name of Pakistan on a global arena

very good point

these taliban lovers only get 5% of the vote in Pakistani elections

they just intimidate their way into power by killing and murdering defenseless women and children and introduce their barbaric laws

I wish the Pakistani Army was as ruthless as the Nazis in dealing with these facist beasts

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

they're not strictly fascists but yea they come close.

nationalists who campaigned for democracy and the removal of the dictator need to be consistent. if they believe in democracy they should have opposed this undemocratic imposition of laws by the threat of force. nothing is worse for democracy than precedents that the system can be overruled if you enough armed men backing you.

but they cant do it lawfully, through a representative system. history shows it, and will show it in the future inshallah.

Isn't some elemens in army wants Taliban style government in Pakistan? Unless army decides what type of government they want, Taliban are not going anywhere.

It must be a faction of army who is still supporting them and keeping them alive unfortunately. Otherwise there would have another lal masjid episode or incident like bombing Bugti in the caves of Baluchistan. Ghadari or Zardari can't do anything except he initiates a longmarch against these mullahs and their supporters in the army.:)

The Army wants to use them to take over Afghanistan if the Karzai Government fails

Basically there are 5 groups at play here:

Pakistani Taliban
Afghani Taliban
Al Qaeda
Haqqani Network
Hekmetyar Group

Haqqani is what the Pakistani Army will rely on if Afghanistan falls apart and they need to secure their western border

Pakistani Taliban have concentrated their attacks in Pakistan. They are led by Meshud.

Afghani Taliban, they are based in Quetta, led by Mullah Omar. They are the ones attacking US and NATO forces in Afghanistan.

Al Qaeda, they live under the shelter of Pakistan Taliban and plot global terrorism such as the recent arrents of 11 Pakistanis in UK

Hekmetyar Group, a warlord financing his forces through drug trade. Basically making a run for power in Afghanistan. Basically, Afghanistan's version of Sadr.

Re: Swat Peace Deal Falls Apart

Swat deal was made under threat of violence by taliban. Sharia cannot be imposed under threat of violence and is thus unislamic.

Militants think they can take what they want on basis of power (guns) so why'd they go 'democratic' way?