Surma like eyeliner

Can you ladies pls help me in finding an eyeliner that can be applied like a surma. I do use surma sometimes but it isn’t as dark as an eyeliner (pencil). And surma is the only thing that doesn’t run. I have tried everything under the sun (at least the ones that have had rave reviews) every kind of liner/pencil runs. And my face is wrecked in a couple of mins. I have even tried the waterproof ones, my eyes can even make those run.

Thanks in advance ladies.

Re: Surma like eyeliner

u should really really try Makeup Forever Aqua Eyeliner....you can put it on your waterline and it literally stays put the whole day...they are completely waterproof and won't run at all....I love it!

Re: Surma like eyeliner

I have the exact opposite problem. I wear surma on my waterline and love how dark it is; however, it never stays in place........I can never get eye liner pencils to give that dark intense look (on my waterline)

Re: Surma like eyeliner

Guac which surma are you using? I am using Surma that I bought from Saudi. It is not dark at all.

Re: Surma like eyeliner

Nothing stays in my eyes, everything either runs/smudges, or disappears.
I’ve tried so many different eyeliners, and now am just resigning to the fact that it’s my eyes, and not the eyeliners that claim to be waterproof, non-smudge, long lasting.

I’ve tried MAC, Urban decay 24/7, guerlain, drug store brands. Surma doesn’t last either.
The only one left to try is Chanel.

Anyway, you were asking about an eyeliner that applied like surma…Guerlain Terracotta loose kohl powder
http://www.sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P116908#

I’ve used this in the past, it doesn’t have long staying power for me, and it’s pricy. It’s well rated on Sephora though, and you can check out the reviews.

Re: Surma like eyeliner

I hv tried bourjoius and it last long. i am satisfied. give one try to it.