surgical strikes?

for last few weeks, i have noticed that indian media, journalists, politicians, bloggers everyone is referring to these strikes all the time. they 200% believe that these strikes did happen. they may not trust Modi 200% but since indian army has also taken an ownership of these strikes, indians believe that the event did happen.

politicians lie all the time but but can indian army’s leadership lie too? and if strikes are a lie, why would indian army become partner of indian govt in this lie? and it is almost impossible to fake such lies at this scale for too long and if indian army is lying, it will get exposed one day and will hurt indian army a lot. so why wud they lie? under public pressure? indian army after all lying on kashmir issue to its public for so long and without any shame. when asked for some proof, indian army and politicians refused under the pretext that it is a highly confidential mission and they cannot disclose the details as they may have to conduct the mission again

Pakistanis on the other hand believe that no such event happened. why? because their army is telling them the same. we were told by our army that no such event happened whatsoever except some heavy shelling that night and that is it. we were told that there is no such proof at all. but we also know that our army lied to us so blatantly in kargil. to this day, i feel crying when i think that our army jawans died in kargil because our army leadership left them abandoned and even refused to take their dead bodies back. so is our army doing the topie drama again and hiding the srikes?

so what is going on? any thoughts? will we ever find the truth? no emotional thoughts please because that will not get us anywhere.

Re: surgical strikes?

If you read carefully your thread and think about Pakistan’s quick response on the day
You can know the truth easily
http://gupshup.org/gs/pakistan-and-world-affairs/665010-india-attacks-loc-via-surgical-strikes.html

Re: surgical strikes?

At best Indian troops went a couple of miles inside Kashmir for a short while. It is likely that Pakistan would have done the same without calling them surgical strikes. Indian Army was quick to state that it had no further plans for more surgical strikes to avoid escalation.

Re: surgical strikes?

Yes there has been numerous reports about Indian version of surgical strikes - They were confirmed when Pak invited BBC, WP, NYT, UN to the location where strikes took place… Locals were also interviewed and in depth investigation was done… Conclusion..

India carried out surgical strikes alright but they were carried out from their side without crossing the LOC. :smiley:

Re: surgical strikes?

They might have not done this time - but they could do in the future with advancement in technology by sending human free mission.

So it is in our best interest to disown all those “strategic assets”!

Re: surgical strikes?

Were they only afraid of leakage of a normal news that time ?
http://gupshup.org/gs/pakistan-and-world-affairs/665085-war-vs-dawn.html

Re: surgical strikes?

No comments , no trust
[RIGHT]آرمی چیف نے سرجیکل اسٹرائیک کا بھارتی دعویٰ مسترد کردیا
آرمی چیف جنرل قمر جاوید نے ناصرف بھارتی ہم منصب کے بیان کو مسترد بلکہ سرجیکل اسٹرائیک کے ممکنہ امکانات کو بھی رد کردیا۔[/RIGHT]
https://fbexternal-a.akamaihd.net/safe_image.php?d=AQDu98nxOn7cQ6eH&w=450&h=236&url=http%3A%2F%2Fi.dawn.com%2Fmedium%2F2017%2F01%2F586e51b814db7.jpg&cfs=1&upscale=1&sx=0&sy=3&sw=500&sh=262&_nc_hash=AQCEv-OjKfAfgnM-Gen Bajwa rubbishes Indian army chief’s claim of ‘so-called surgical strikes’ on Pakistan
“Pakistan’s armed forces are fully geared to respond to any aggression by India,” says COAS General Qamar Bajwa.
DAWN.COM

Re: surgical strikes?

No comments as story is hidden
[RIGHT]ایل او سی سے ‘گرفتار’ فوجی بھارت کے حوالے
چندو بابو لال چوہان کوگذشتہ برس ‘سرجیکل اسٹرائیکس’ کے روزپاکستانی حدود میں داخل ہونے پرمبینہ طور پرگرفتار کیا گیا تھا۔[/RIGHT]
https://fbexternal-a.akamaihd.net/safe_image.php?d=AQCPUfBBd0ceVSfB&w=450&h=236&url=http%3A%2F%2Fi.dawn.com%2Fmedium%2F2017%2F01%2F58831cf086cf2.jpg&cfs=1&upscale=1&sx=0&sy=38&sw=500&sh=262&_nc_hash=AQABoEJVy-E35V19Indian soldier in custody since Sept 29 returned by Pakistan
ISPR says soldier deserted his post due to mistreatment by seniors, “has been convinced to return to his own country”.

Re: surgical strikes?

lol, when u got their soldiers shaming them publicly, how u expect “surgical strikes”.

this is not a video game, its reality. But they(bharat) can keep dreaming about it. lol

Re: surgical strikes?

if it was a dream , why no statement about this ordinary soldier , months gone .

Re: surgical strikes?

Re: surgical strikes?

:k:

Re: surgical strikes?

We are not afraid of this
Not new for us
US , NATO , Afghanistan , Iran already did that

No guarantee that there will no surgical strike in future: Rajnath Singh
International-The Indian Express-03-Feb-2017