Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

^ no one insulted anyone.
and neither did i say i have knowledge of it. Please stop twisting my words :)

so getting back on the topic, it wud be better if people just stopped passing their own fatwas, and actually studied the following before passing conclusions:

  1. the historical background of the hijaab.
  2. historical background of mecca, preislamic period, also known as the jahilliyah.
  3. the dress code for women in arabia, and for further enlightenment, the dress code of the byzantinian and the sassanian empires.
  4. a thorough study of the arabic words, and their roots.
  5. actually opening the Quran :)
  6. the difference of opinion and what scholars actually conclude on the words used in the Quran.

Thanks.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

That's your proof? How does that proove niqaab is mandated or even encouraged in Islam? In fact, how does that even proove that niqaab is even part of Islam?

Have you read the Quran...? Try it sometime.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

So what your saying is that Nikab and Hijab was the dress code of Arabian women, so is cultural?

[QUOTE]

  1. a thorough study of the arabic words, and their roots.

[/QUOTE]

What is the root of Khimaar and what does it mean?

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

We are all criticising what he said etc. but why dont you take a look at how so-called Muslim countries would treat a white person if they went to their countries to live there? would they let them wear what they want and do what they want? I dont think so.

to be honest, living in uk, I dont feel any kind of restriction on how I should dress or practice my religion. I feel free to practice my religion as I wish.

I cant say the same for islamic countries....they wouldnt tolerate ANYTHING.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

PCG If you can't read english, i'll tell you. I never said i'll give proof, i said to investigate it yourself before you give out conclusions.

So please, learn english first, let alone the Quran.

roadrunner, i didn't put out any conclusions like the scholars on here :)

I gave u tips as to how you can arrive at a conclusion.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Hey, first learn to spell ‘prove’ correctly :hehe:

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

We're going in circles. I already know what the Quran says on the topic, so I'm certain that the niqaab is not Islamic. If you want to contradict me, the onus is on you to provide the proof. If you can't, don't insult people who don't agree with you.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

^ insult seems to circling u.

No one insulted anyone in this thread.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

2 wrongs dont make a right do they so this is a bogus argument
people who are living in UK are part of UK, their primary concern is with their life in Uk and not someone else’s life in the country they or their parents or garndparents came from. I mean if you are a brit .. why is there even an argument that you can not protest what u think is not right in the UK, because your family is originally from Sudan and the whole scene there sucks..

So yeah the so called muslim countries suck at how they work, and that is why I dont live there, but that does not mean that as a muslim I can not sound my displeasure at what I see in my homeland, the homeland my parents immigrated to.

I am glad that you feel u can practise you religion as you wish. Niether I, nor anyone in my family wears niqaab so this does not really apply, but its just the principle..Jack Straw can put the facade of some logic on his inherent bias, but one does not have to buy it.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Pakistan treats non Muslims pretty well.

Christians are allowed to drink. So are Jews and Hindus.

Chief Justice in Pakistan is a Hindu.

Churches, cathedrals are in Pakistan.

Sikhs can dress how they want.

Muslim women can dress in Niqab and Hijab or wear nothing on their head.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

what about saudi?

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

A female wont actually be punished for not wearing the Niqaab Subhanallah :) Why are we so bitter towards the poor women that wear it. Certainly they are much more pious than women who don't wear it and of course they will get more reward for wearing it even if it's not Fard its an extra form of Ibaadah.

Niqaab is 'Islamic' because if it wasn't Rasulallah's wives wouldn't observe it but that's not to say its mandatory like the hijaab. It's an extra form of worship and making ALLAH happy. Like praying extra nawafil, we don't need to do it but we do it to be better muslims, become more pious and gain extra reward.

Allah SWT actually sent his salaam to Khadijah RA through the Angel Jibrail because she was one of the four perfect women in islam because she had many special and noble attributes but two of her most blessed traits were 'Hayya' and 'Sabr'. Imagine ALLAH swt Himself was so happy with her that he sent his Salaam to her through the Angel Subhanallah:)

We should stick up for the women who wear Niqaab rather than mock them and say that it is a useless thing because they are striving to please ALLAH with their actions and just because we are too weak to do it we should at least praise them for what they are doing as it's so hard to even do a little good in the western society where anything that doesn't conform to society is looked down upon. Jack staw had no excuse to say what he did,

there has never been a threat from any niqaabi,
A Niqaabi has never attacked or raped anyone
A Niqaabi has not harmed or bombed anyone, there are no reports of vandalising or threatening behaviour from any niqaabi so why is he so insecure and intimidated by them? I thought the UK was a so-called free and civillised society where we were free to practise our religion and way of life without inteference....Today it's the niqaab tomorrow the hijaab, then the beard.....where will it stop.

There are some things we can't tolerate as muslims and this is one of them.
T

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Who knows. And it doesnt bother me much.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Your knowledge of Islam is as poor as your knowledge of British society. The wives of the Prophet were special cases, not ordinary women like you. There were many enemies at the time of the Prophet, and his wives needed protecting from these people.

[33:32] O wives of the prophet, you are not the same as any other women, if you observe righteousness. (You have a greater responsibility.) Therefore, you shall not speak too softly, lest those with disease in their hearts may get the wrong ideas; you shall speak only righteousness.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Maybe my knowledge is poor, May ALLAH increase in Ameen. All i’m saying is it isn’t fard but many people are mocking the women who wear it and I was trying to say that we shouldn’t mock. In islam A women doesnt have to cover her face but they do it for extra virtues. They imitate the mothers of the believers, and to perfect your character who better to imitate than them?

Jazak ALLAH, May ALLAH guide us to the correct path and increase our knowledge, ameen.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Noone is mocking women who wear it. It's just not Fard is the most anyone has said on here. Social exclusion was brought up, but I dont care if some people want to be socially excluded from jobs or not. I'm not interested in anything they do.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

PLease do not generalize, you don't know anything about middle east where the highest number of naqaabis reside, you will be surprised to see niqaab ki aaR mein kiya kiya hota hai.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

It is saddening to see Muslims passing verdicts without knowledge of the scripture but based on the habits of their people and what they heard from their mommies and clean-shaven Disco-Mullahs.

Fear Allaah my brothers, you’ll be answerable to Him on the Day of Judgement for misguiding yourselves and others.

Allaah knows best but all the scholars of the past believed that the face veil is Islamic, nobody said it was un-Islamic, a minority however said although it is better it is optional, majority maintained it is compulsory except in certain cases. The people started to go astray after our first generations (Nabi :saw: and Sahaabah, Taabey-een, Taabey-Taabeyeen) so cling to their way. Whichever ruling you believe it should be on sincere research, knowledge and conviction instead of on whim and desire because the people who change religion fro whim and desire are doomed.

Remember that besides the Qur’aan we also have the Sunnah (Example) of the Prophet :saw: to follow because the Qur’aan tells us to follow it. If we didn’t follow the Sunnah, we wouldn’t know how to pray because the Qur’aan doesn’t give the method only the order, people would start doing aarti and say it is Salaah.

Re: Straw extends attack on veils (Merged)

Well whiteys get treated like gods in Pakistan and the Middle East, there’s certain rules which apply to everyone but they’re even exempt from these because Pakis/Arabs are arselickers (which is wrong).

Muslim lands don’t boast about the freedom to do as you will, Muslim socities openly say that we have rules and regulations which everyone must abide by including dress code but these countries have no such rules, punks, chavs etc. can dress as they please, people can walk around practically nude but Muslims can’t cover.

What I’m saying is they should stop calling Muslim lands oppressive and admit that they themselves restrict freedom of expression in their countries.

First they banned us from condemning what our terrorist goverment is doing to the Muslims around the world, indirect incitement to terror or whatever, we couldn’t criticise those who attack the honour of our Prophet :saw: (because it’s fundamentalist/extremist and everyone has the right to free speech but Muslims), ban on our free speech, now on the way we dress, where are they going to draw the line? Next maybe halal meat will be banned because it’s inhumane but kosher will still be allowed just as the French banned Muslimahs from wearing Hijaab but Sikhs could still keep uncut hair and beard.

They don’t let us be even in our own lands, lol they say they want to liberate us, we don’t need their depressing, shallow and immoral ways, tossers. I swear the more westernisation that I see back home the less content and depressed our society is becoming, I can’t talk for all of Pakistan but I can for my people.