^ i do not see anything wrong with Pagluu's post. He has refered **his facts **back to the authentic Sunni books.
Brothers Pathan Bhai and Pagluu – does the following make sense?!!!
3)Tareekh Tabari gives accounts of the events and say that Hz Umar was seeking to deny the information of Prophet's departure and was in fact threatening to kill people who said that the Prophet (pbuh) was dead. He continued to do so until Hz Abu Bakr arrived and then he became "normal" and then they both went to BB Ayesha at Prophet's house. There the Prophet of Allah asks for a pen and paper to write an "important message" to which Umar was seriously against (read Sahi Bukhari for details on this important event).
The above states that the Prophet (saw) had died and that Hz. Umar (ra) was ‘seeking to deny the information of Prophet's departure and was in fact threatening to kill people who said that the Prophet (pbuh) was dead’.
And then Strange thing happens
He continued to do so until Hz Abu Bakr arrived and then he became "normal" and then they both went to BB Ayesha at Prophet's house. There the Prophet of Allah asks for a pen and paper to write an "important message" to which Umar was seriously against
Does this mean the Prophet (saw) became alive again and asked Hz. Umar (ra) and Hz. Abu Bakr (ra) for paper????????
Mixing the events up????!!!!
4)At the house of the Prophet (pbuh), infront of the pure body of the Prophet BB Ayesha is reported to have said: "If anyone amongst you used to worship Muhummud (saws) then Muhummud is dead but (if any one of) you used to worship Allah then Allah is alive and shall never die. Then she recited a verse from the Quran about the past Prophets being dead (Sahi Bukhar). Did any one worship Prophet Mohammad (pbuh)? What kind of condolence was that? It indeed is very different from how the Ahlay Bayt (as) felt at tht time!
Wrong again!!!!!
"If anyone amongst you used to worship Muhummud (saws) then Muhummud is dead but (if any one of) you used to worship Allah then Allah is alive and shall never die.”
These famous words were uttered by Hz. Abu Bakr (ra) to re-assure the people who were devastated and overwhelmed by the death of the Prophet (saw).
Otherwise good questions brother Pagluu and these have been comfortably addressed over the centuries.
It is the last days of Ramadan so busy or want utilise time in better things – I’ll attempt to answer/address them after Eid – Insha’Allah