Something good out of India!

Arrest for Prophet Mohammad image
By Ram Dutt Tripathi
BBC News, Lucknow

Islam considers images of the Prophet Mohammad blasphemy
Police in India’s Uttar Pradesh state have arrested a publisher for a sketch of the Prophet Mohammad in a book.
They said the drawing was likely to cause outrage among the Muslim community as images of the Prophet are considered blasphemy in Islam.

The publisher, Amit Agrawal, was arrested in the city of Merrut, 80km (50 miles) east of Delhi.

In 2001, Time magazine apologised to Muslims after an image of the Prophet Mohammad sparked riots in Kashmir.

A court remanded Mr Agrawal in custody on Tuesday for 14 days.

Idol worship

The book, named Gyan Ganga, or River of Knowledge, was published by the Heavens Publications House in the Civil Lines area of Merrut.

District magistrate, Chandra Bhanu, said 18 copies of the book had been seized.

Kashmiri Muslims were angry at the image in Time

Authorities took action after a complaint by local Muslims who said their feelings had been hurt by the book.

They said the sketch was against their religion, which bans idol worship.

A police inquiry revealed the same sketch had appeared in another book, published from the Una district in the Himalayan hill state of Himachal Pradesh.

But the private publication was of so small a circulation it drew no complaints.

In the 2001 Time magazine riots, students in Indian-administered Kashmir offended by the image threw stones at police and burned several cars, while security forces responded with tear gas and bamboo canes.

The magazine was removed from news stands by a government order in Muslim Malaysia.

The picture - part of a special report on “Jerusalem at the time of Jesus” - showed the Prophet meeting the Archangel Gabriel to receive a revelation from God.

In 2002, several Muslim countries banned an issue of Newsweek magazine that carried an image of the Prophet Mohammad from an undated Turkish manuscript.

Well, this is a good reflection of Indias Secular intent.. Fair and equal..

Re: Something good out of India!

Belief of Hindus forbids killing of cows. Killing of cows may cause outrage in Hindu community.

Any one thinks killing of cows will be banned in UP any time?
then it will be fair and equal..

Re: Something good out of India!

Yeah... thats true.. Still, shows India is willing to go out of its way to apease Muslims.

Re: Something good out of India!

while that is usually a good thing and generally benign…such practices usually undermine India’s secularism. another example would be India’s separate laws for muslims. i think accommodation is fine and sometimes even necessary…but some issues remain controversial.

Re: Something good out of India!

It was my understanding that killing cows was illegal.

At least when my Mom was in India back in the early 60's (before she left for the West), killing a cow would be a one way ticket to a human bonfire...

One couldn't even harass the monkeys that would make a mess of things for fear of raising the ire of neighbours...

Needless to say, ban the cow killing. It is in fact no sweat off our back.

Re: Something good out of India!

pico uncle, i am from india, and we shoot, kill and eat monkeys. whatcha on about. which part is your mommy from?

Re: Something good out of India!

I think making laws that dont infringe on the rights and sentiments of all religous communities is fair and secualr, its only when the govt begins to pick and choose when secular govt is threatened. If you make laws solely for benefit of Muslims, that wrong, but then if you did the same for all communities within reasonable limits, thats fair.
There is no reason why killing cows shouldnt be banned. If the Indian govt can go out of their way to defend Muslims sentiment, Muslims in India should be willing to do the same to accomodate the Hindus.
India should allow the import of Beef under a licence sysytem like Pkaistan has for minorities who want to purchase alcahol. Muslims should apply for licences to import beef.

Re: Something good out of India!

but many hindus and christians eat beef, so it's not as if only muslims are the 'culprits'. besides you gotta have freedom to eat what you want, or next thing you know busybodies will be tellign you what to put in yoru mouth in the morning, and what ot put in the evening. but religion, yeah, it's fine to make a show of such things becuase people are still backward and religion is their opium. and i hope the book will still be available minus the picture, or else its' trampling on freedom of speech.

Re: Something good out of India!

i though india export beef to pakistan that is halal too.

Re: Something good out of India!

But by allowing the slaughter of Cows, Indian govt is overlooking the sentiment of it Hindu polpulation. You cant pick and choose among relgious groups, which you support and which not in a secualr society. Govt cant take sides.

Re: Something good out of India!

yeah, and we should ban slaughter of chicken, for it offends jain beliefs. just scrap all religion related laws. if i wanna chop up my cow, i should be allowed to. if i wanna draw a sketch of prophet mohammed and put it up in my room, thats okay too.

Re: Something good out of India!

if beef is banned then one day muslims can ask for pork to be banned…and so on.

Re: Something good out of India!

Look, one magzines makes some mistake and they stone the police and burn cars.

  1. Is voilence the only source of protest?
  2. Let anyone who says that Muslims are oppressed in Kashmir know how freely they master the riots.

Re: Something good out of India!

How did Mahammad look like? If i drew your picture and wrote Mohammad under it will it be a blasphemy? What if i digitally removed your beard, will it still be a blasphemy?what if i wrote mohammad next to a girls picture? will you be isulted because it is a blasphemy or because it was a woman’s picture? what if i drew a burkha on the woman and then wrote mohammad next to it? what if…inquiring mind needs to know.

Re: Something good out of India!

I think any image of the prophet, even if its me with a beard is blasphemous if it says Prophet under it... Dont ask me, ask the religion...

Re: Something good out of India!

Laal, this isnt about Kashmir! I didnt put that in the article, the writer of the article added that in.
Still, to answer your question…

  1. I never said anyone should use violence, you just ASSumed I did.
  2. I dont know what your saying here..

Re: Something good out of India!

And why not? If you have Pork selling in licenced shops the same way as liquor is, then I see no harm in that…

Re: Something good out of India!

Anything within reasonable limits. Certain laws are to way outside the reasonable limit. Banning the slaughter of all animals would be inpossible to do. But, banning the slaghter of cows in India, or banning imagesd of the Prophet, or banning pork (with some exceptions) is not unreasonable.

Re: Something good out of India!

Im a compelteyl secualr person, but lets face reality. While we all want to get rid of religoun and religous laws, you have to accept that people even in Secualr socities are not going to settle for a state devoid of religous sensitivity. By that I mean, a state like Turkey, which is completely insensative to the views of its relgious population...

Re: Something good out of India!

..fair…
If i drew picture of a man and wrote Mohammad under it..I will be commiting blasphemy? Does it apply to muslim and non muslim as well? what is the punishment for such a crime? Who is appointed to carry out punishment? Allah or any of the self-proclaimed guardian of the religion? is drawing picture the only thing mentioned that is punishable or every violation of hadith edict? I can understand your outrage if somebody tried to draw his picture in degrading way, Just like one will be offended if somebody try to picture their loved ones in degrading way but this was not the case. Besides, even in pakistan, there must be countless time that a child might have innocently drawn the prophet’s picture.