So she is in a fix now.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

Maybe it's just me, but I don't think a girl going to see her family twice a week or more is anything for the husband to complain about. Unless there's something more to it that I haven't read/understood here, I don't think she's being unreasonable.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

That makes sense. If she's not neglecting her duties to her in laws whhy does husband have such an issue with it?

Re: So she is in a fix now.

I find this situation to be rather demeaning...if she is truly caring about her husband and in laws why shudnt she be allowed to visit her family twice a week...after all from birth to youth she was with them,,,and yet she left their home, her comfort zone to be with her husband and his family ...and plus she spends 5 days a week with her husbands family and yet she should turn her back on her family as even 2 days a week are unacceptable? Why?

any reasonable guy shouldnt truly have a problem with that... there has to be more to this than just her visiting them twice a week

Re: So she is in a fix now.

It's a catch 22 situation in my opnion. From what the story seems like so far, neither the girl nor the guy is in the complete right or complete wrong.

As an outsider, one would assume that because she is fulfilling all her duties with inlaws and domestically, and is giving respect and living happily in the in laws place, it's only fair that she gets to interact with her family as much as she wants. Commonsense will say that.

However, some may agree with me some may disagre (depending on your POV and thinking) that once your married especially early on in your marriage at times it gets highly pressured, it's a new set up a lot of emotions especially for the girl, since she's making more of the move. However, this situation does not seem to be the type where hubby is being cruel in otherways but rather just needs time to get on with their life. In my opnion the girl should just go with the flow, really its the first couple of yrs in the marriage life that everything is so watched out for, so much happeneing, once you've eased into it, and got it all up and working, then start doing other things.

Some may disagree by thinking it's not only the girl that makes a move, and why should she have to leave the family etc, but really thats the way marriage has been working for centuries. It dosen't mean never meet and interact with families, it just means be a tad flexible, and eventually it'll all pan out.

Like I said it's a catch 22 situation.. Hope it works out for the girl.. It's all about taking it easy :)

Re: So she is in a fix now.

I think maybe it's not the actual visiting her family that is bothering him, since obviously he did not object to that initially. Maybe it's more about what other obligations and interests he would like to pursue that for some reason he feels get put on the back burner.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

How about they make it equal and separate the guy from his parents as well? Lets see how the guy handles being away from his parent. This should make him realize the way the girl is feeling.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

family is important though, not sure whether visiting twice a week is a bit too much, it might be but i would feel empty if i couldn’t have family gatherings or family around during atleast special occasions. i mean the husband and wife can’t just gaze at each other every second of the day and week, why must a woman leave her family totally and completely after marriage, husband/wife should be priority but family should be as well.

a girl should be expected to forget her parents/siblings completely after marriage is such a totally frustrating thing. the family was with her for 20+ years of her life and she’s expected to just forget they exist after she ties the knot, God help me that Sucks! give her atleast those Eids, thanksgivings, other holidays ok one holiday a year?? no? :bummer:

Re: So she is in a fix now.

I dont know if that will be received on the equal grounds. It becomes so magnified and exaggerated when it comes to the husband-his parents relationship. Well we already know and seen even if a son’s tone changes after marriage, he is considered every possible worst beta and bhai on earth. Anyways its the best convenient manner to expect the girl to dump her family and never look back or she will not be a good wife and all that. Imagine we colleagues suggesting her this and she might be even forbidden to come to the college and sit with us on the grounds that oh her chalak colleagues teach her bad things :blush: :halo:

Re: So she is in a fix now.

just ask her if her brother gets married tomo and her bhabi kept visiting her parents every now and again , and her brother wasn't happy with all that, what advice she would give to her bhabi to make the situation better..

Re: So she is in a fix now.

as her friend not sure how you should approach it since you're the third party. but something about visiting twice a week every week for the whole day is a bit messed up. why can't she just visit the parents on special occasions and get to know her hubs better the other days of the week, that doesn't seem bad at all. the hubs can meet her halfway

Re: So she is in a fix now.

sounds convincing :k: But maybe if I tell her this way she would consider it a taunt I dont know. Its not a very nice analogy to start comparing like yours and mine. A wife and husband should understand their obligations and responsibilities without having given better examples. Sometimes they just work opposite.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

there should be a way anyway. She didnt come to college today. Lets see what she has to tell us tomorrow and maybe we will sort some way out for her to help her manage the things. I personally agree after shadi your husband and homes needs the most and best of your attention. Maybe I will suggest her to tell her parents she would visit less because she wants to spend more time with her inlaws and husband in order to understand them more. This much sacrifice wouldnt hurt them much I think. They should be rather happy that their daughter is rather wise because most of the times girls find it hard to manage in inlaws family, become irrational and endup destroying their marital life. No one's parents would want that for their daughter Im sure.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

well that's what I was trying to say , just make her think as a third-party person to this situation , a third-party person that can see the situation from husband's perspective.. that could be her brother.. may be she could understand it better that way!

Re: So she is in a fix now.

I think it is imperative for her to focus on her life with her husband. My brother told me soon after my nikah that the most important male in my life is essentially my husband now and I should consider his wants and needs before all else's.

This is not to say that my father or brothers are not important now. My brother is younger than me by a few years, but there is a lot of wisdom in what he said. What I feel in this situation is that she should not spend time overnight at her parents' home for the time being. Even if it is just for one day or two in a week. She can go there when the husband is at work or in between, but the point is that it should not at this time infringe on their time together, or whatever time they do get together.

It really is not a matter of her family or his in my opinion, and who is doing how much for whose parents. It's more about the couple. His family is conveniently right there, at home. And she can attend to them nicely, being the person you have described her to be. Her family is not so conveniently present right there. Think of it as her visiting some random person's house on a weekly basis early in the marriage. Perhaps and most likely he wants them to focus on a life together, on building one and establishing strong bonds together, which btw is a BIG blessing. It is marvellous and it is something to be thankful for that the boy is possessive of her and wants perhaps to work on THEIR life together. There are cases where girls don't get that and the boy couldn't care less if she was there or not.

Successful marriages I've seen, including the older lot of my parents' friends, I have observed that the woman always puts the husband first and is there to greet them every day when they get home and basically make them feel like kings. Husbands, usually less expressive, acutely feel their wives absence and though are appreciative of them when they are around, it is not expressed in so many words. Except in the displeasure when they aren't there.

That is my very humble opinion, that for the betterment of her marriage, which is her life from hereonin, she should make sure that her visits do not infringe upon her husband and her potential alone time, whenever that may be. She can increase phone calls but I would discourage her from attending any call from anyone when she and her husband are together. It shows how much importance you give the other person, and again in my opinion, men like to know they are important just as much as females do. Whenever my husband and I are together, if my phone rings and it's a friend, I almost always let it go unanswered or only have a very short conversation in which i relay that I am busy right now with the husband and I shall get back to the friend. If it is his family or mine, I shall take the call, relay that I am with him and listen to what they have to say because that is giving them respect as elders. My family members usually understand and give me space. His are fine because if the conversation goes longer, I offer him the phone so that he is involved.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

Wow!

Re: So she is in a fix now.

Honestly I don't know why people bother to invest in their daughters at all only to be shut out of her life when she gets married.
Why spend money feeding her, educating her. Why spend time nursing her, comforting her. Why not just leave her in a basket outside her future mother inlaws house as a baby.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

^^tell me about it

Re: So she is in a fix now.

Neglect the whole world rather than your marriage partner:
Nabi (SAW) confirmed the advice of Salman to Abu-Darda [RA] for neglecting his wife. “Verily there is a right of your wife over you.” (Nasai Hadith2391)

Re: So she is in a fix now.

It is not a competition. We are advised in religion even that if there is an argument between a husband and wife, let the other party win. They are her parents true, perhaps he is not seeing it in that sense.Perhaps he sees it as something as basic as her going to someone's house and them(the couple) not having as much time together as he would like consequently together alone.

Rather than getting excited over a possible perspective I am offering, not one I necessarily agree is correct, it should be accepted as a perspective which may fit and possibly help this girl in maintaining harmony in her marriage which is the basic purpose here I am sure of all good intentioned respondees.

Re: So she is in a fix now.

if you're a guy thank god you feel this way, you're an awesome husband to your wife probably

[quote]
Think of it as her visiting some random person's house on a weekly basis early in the marriage.
[/quote]

that's a good way of looking at it