Sindh Festival in Moenjodaro

[khoji]

Re: Sindh Festival in Moenjodaro

@Sachaydino

He was just giving reference which is normally used in envy, hatred or jealousy by someone so nothing wrong here. However I have never heard that Hazrat Ali ever used as Ali ibn Abi Talib, as Abu Talib died as unbeliever even so much requests by Mohammad PBUH while his favorite unlce was on death bed.

I know there is nothing wrong with his message. The point was that he used wrong example. Nobody is ‘jealous’ or envied of Muawiyah. So ‘Bughz e Muawiyah’ is a wrong term. If anything it is always ‘Bughz e Ali’ which makes people go astray.

Your logic of not calling Imam Ali as Ali ibn Abi Talib, is simply pitiful. Just think before typing. I don’t think even Homo Erectus would say that. Belief, or lack of belief, does not change one’s parenthood. Thus Ali would always be called son of Abu Talib, Umar will always be called son of Khattab, Khalid would always be called son of Walid. It does not matter whether those fathers were Muslims or not.