Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

On Friday night, 9 of June 2006, it was reported by the US military that three men, two Saudi nationals and a Yemeni, committed suicide at Camp 1 in Guantanamo Bay.

Detainees in Camp 1 are held in cages with very thin wire mesh. The men died by strangulation with their bed-sheets - a lawyer who has seen these conditions said that the mesh is far too thin to fit a sheet through. The only way they could have strangulated themselves is to have tied the sheets to their toilets and literally pulled until they strangled themselves. This raises the question of how they died.

These men were also held without access to the outside world – they had little, if any, communication with their families through censored letters and did not have access to legal representation, hence little is known about their cases. It is not known if they were taking part in the hunger strike and if this could have contributed to their deaths.

On Sunday, a US Interior Ministry statement identified the two Saudis as 30 year old Mani Shaman Turki al-Habardi al-Utaybi and 21 year old Yassar Talal al-Zahrani, but gave no further details about them. The Yemeni citizen was identified as 28 year old Salah Al Din Ali Abdullah Ahmed Al Salami.

The US army described this act of desperation as “an act of asymmetrical warfare” and a “PR stunt” by Al-Qaeda operatives being held at Guantanamo. After four years of torture and abuse, no evidence has been presented to substantiate that any of the detainees were with Al-Qaeda and less than 10 of the over 450 men held there have been charged and none have been put on trial.

Abu Bakr Deghayes, brother of Brighton resident Omar Deghayes, said, "We are very worried about Omar. In the four years he has been held in Guantanamo we have had so little news from him. We know he was desperate enough to join the hunger strike last year.

There should be access for families to see detainees, especially after such a terrible incident. We ask for an independent investigation into the sad deaths of these three men."

In recent months, there have been many calls at all levels for the closure of Guantanamo, from national governments, human rights NGOs, the European Union and the United Nations. These calls need to be translated into concrete action on the part of all world government to close the camp and have all the detainees currently held there returned to countries where they will not face further torture and abuse.

This action needs to be taken urgently to avoid any further fatalities.
An international day of protest is being organised for the 15th of July when several demonstrations are planned where we anticipate simultaneous delivery of the copies of this petition to be handed to the US embassies across the world.

We, the undersigned, demand the following of the American Administration:

  1. That the American Administration allow an independent enquiry into the deaths of these three young men. The enquiry to be constituted under the auspices of an internationally recognised independent authority like the United Nation’s Human Rights Commission.

  2. That all those currently held at Guantanamo be immediately sent to countries where they will not face further abuses of their basic human rights and before further tragedy strikes.

  3. That the families of all the detainees held at Guantanamo be given access to their loved ones still held at Guantanamo.

  4. That all the detainees be given access to medical personnel for an independent assessment of their health.

  5. That Guantanamo and other illegally constituted prisons where individuals are held without access to a properly constituted legal process be closed immediately.

Sign the Petition

SOURCE: National Guantanamo Coalition, guantanamo.org.uk

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

Your prayers are answered! Your comrades will now have more rights.

US detainees to get Geneva rights
** All US military detainees, including those at Guantanamo Bay, are to be treated in line with the minimum standards of the Geneva Conventions. ** The White House announced the shift in policy almost two weeks after the US Supreme Court ruled that the conventions applied to detainees.
President Bush had long fought the idea that US detainees were prisoners of war entitled to Geneva Convention rights.
The Pentagon outlined the new standards to the military in a 7 July memo.
The directive says all military detainees are entitled to humane treatment and to certain basic legal standards when they come to trial, as required by Common Article 3 of the Geneva Conventions.

	     	                 	     	                 	     	            **     	     	            It is not really a reversal of policy - humane treatment has always been the standard     	     	            **     	     	            
	     	                 	     	                 	     	            Tony Snow,      	     	            
	     	            White House spokesman      	     	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	                                 
       	      	             The Bush administration has come under intense and sustained international criticism for its treatment of prisoners held at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba. 

The military has been using the site to house hundreds of detainees, many believed to have been picked up off battlefields in Afghanistan.
When the detention centre was established in 2002, President Bush ordered that detainees be treated “humanely, and to the extent appropriate and consistent with military necessity, in a manner consistent with the principles of Geneva”.
His spokesman Tony Snow said on Tuesday that the Pentagon directive did not represent a change: “It is not really a reversal of policy. Humane treatment has always been the standard.”
** Court steps in **
At the end of June, the Supreme Court ruled 5-3 that the Bush administration did not by itself have the authority to order that the detainees be tried by military commission.

	     	                 	     	                 	     	                                         COURT RULING                              	     	            
 	     	                 	     	            **     	     	            We conclude that the military commission convened to try Hamdan lacks power to proceed     	     	            **     	     	            
	     	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	            
	     	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	                                                      	                 	     	            Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader     	     	                 	     	                                                	                 	     	                 	     	                 	     	                                 
       	      	             It said its decision was based on both US military law and the Geneva Conventions - asserting for the first time in US law that the detainees were entitled to Geneva protections. 

But the Supreme Court left open the possibility that the detainees could be tried by military commission if Congress established an appropriate legal framework for doing so.
The Senate Judiciary Committee began hearings on the issue on Tuesday morning, just as news of the new military policy became public.
Daniel Dell’Orto, a defence department lawyer who was the first to testify, said there were about 1,000 detainees in US military custody around the world.
Guantanamo Bay holds an estimated 450. Mr Dell’Orto did not say where the others were being held.
The new Pentagon policy applies only to detainees being held by the military, and not to those in CIA custody, such as alleged mastermind of the 11 September attacks, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.
The Geneva Conventions, which were passed in the wake of World War II, are meant to guarantee minimum standards of protection for non-combatants and former combatants in war.

                                Story from BBC NEWS:

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

Is that ex-Iraqi Information Minister in new uniform? :CareBear:

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

He would be! If USA was putting bullet holes in the heads of Gitmo inmates. Or AlJanaza (woops al-jazeera) was airing "head chopping ceremonies" of the Arab inmates of Gitmo.

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!


Not really, what the torture still existed which was against Geneva convention.... if the prisoners were really being treated "humanely" why were they in Guantanamo facility? It is white lies that makes this guy a brother of ex-Iraqi information minister.

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

Gitmo is for trouble makers mostly picked up from the Afghan battle fields. We shouldn't expect they be treated as "ghar-damaad" (live-in son-in-law). Read what happened to the German, or Japanese prisoners of WWII. They were "interrogated" before being brought to regular POW camps. That interrogation included torture to some degree. However that was easier than how we do "chitrol" to petty criminals in Pakistan.

The treatment of POWs in US back then and now is pretty humane compared to how the attackers of US treat US prisoners. Ever heard of what happened to the abducted US soldiers in Japan or now in Afghanistan? Where was the Geneva convention then or now?

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!


Read it again, I am talking about what Tony Snow said and what actually happens in Gitmo, period. I am not comparing Pak army/police tortures, German prisoners etc..... simply what Tony Snow said and compared with what actually happens.

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!

Tony Snow may have his point of view.

How many Gitmo inmates have been released with limbs missing, nails pulled, tounges chopped, ears cut, or nose removed?

Re: Sign the Petition: Close Down Guantanamo!


Ask the ones who are released how peacefully they lived in Gitmo.