Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

[diwana]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

Is it confirmed she died?

If so, then

ILWIAR.

Though committing suicide is not allowed in Islam, she must have been very depressed. May she gets pardoned and her family goes through the losses with sabar.

As to some of the "lol" and tangential posts? It's just plain pathetic.

[Doppleganger]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

I wouldn't lol at what she did, but it is still a haram act.

[kakaballi]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

I don't understand, how does killing herself accomplish anything? I'm sorry but I just can't feel the sympathy here.

I can't feel the sympathy for ther either. Committing suicide is not the solution, it must be discouraged. Tv channels are putting headlines over this .... crazy dumb people.

Innalillahe Wainnailaihe rajioon.

Committing suicide is not a rational choice but an emotional decision. She was not trying to 'make a point' or 'accomplish something' or 'trying to find a solution'.

I sincerely hope none of us have to go through what she did and then have armchair warriors judging us. Really really disgusting reactions I see here.

[rizla86]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

Armchair warriors? So she lost a husband, does that give her the right to kill herself? I have seen people go through much worse than that, and still come out stronger. This woman instead chose a one way route to hell.

[Faris_Udeen]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

I have seen people go through much worse than that, and still come out stronger. This woman instead chose a one way route to hell.

True but not everyone reacts in the same way to emotions. I cannot blame her for choosing a one way route to hell, only pray she winds up in a better place.

As for right to suicide? That in itself is a sensitive topic, perhaps in her shoes I would live to see justice and make a stand... but perhaps I might just give up and keel over either way she made her choice and I cannot blame her only have empathy for her.

[waleedhbk]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

@BarbieCue

Shumaila Kanwal, the wife of one of the Pakistanis shot and killed by Raymond Davis has tried to commit suicide by eating rat poison. Ali Naqi, a doctor in Faisalabad city treating Shumaila Kanwal, said she told him she took the poison because she believes her husband’s suspected killer will be freed without trial. “He is being treated like a VIP. I want justice”, she said.

Update: She is no more. http://dunyanews.tv/index.php?key=Q2F0SUQ9MiNOaWQ9MTk2NzU=

Innalillahe Wainnailaihe rajioon.

:(

[PatriotX]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

Inna lillahe Wainna ilaihe rajioon.

not the time to be friggin judgemental, to condone or condemn her actions, God will be the judge of that. as humans try and feel her pain, extent of her misery, helplessness...to look at the bigger picture, EMPATHY is what is needed and what we sadly lack most at times like this.

[Afshi]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

Armchair warriors? So she lost a husband, does that give her the right to kill herself? I have seen people go through much worse than that, and still come out stronger. This woman instead chose a one way route to hell.

I agree.

[system]

Re: Shumaila Kanwal commits suicide

Armchair warriors? So she lost a husband, does that give her the right to kill herself? I have seen people go through much worse than that, and still come out stronger. This woman instead chose a one way route to hell.

route to hell?....i am glad that you are NOT the Judge...Allah Ta'ala has His own criteria of judgment, Things can never be judged in black n white...so let the route to hell or heaven be left to Allah who is a better judge than all of us....