I think this may not be a bad idea.
Afghan Border Row Has US Envoy in Hot Water With Karzai Govt. – News from Antiwar.com
Afghan Border Row Has US Envoy in Hot Water With Karzai Govt.
Pakistan Endorses State Department’s Comments, Afghans Fume
by Jason Ditz, October 28, 2012
Last week’s comments from US Special Ambassador Marc Grossman have built up steam over the weekend, with the US State Department reiterating that it is believes the Afghan-Pakistan border is where it has always been and Afghan officials up in arms at the perceived betrayal.
Apparently unbeknownst to US officials the Afghan-Pakistan border, the Durand Line, is a contentious topic in Afghanistan, where officials are pretty sure that a good chunk of Pakistan’s Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) should belong to them.
Pakistan, of course, has a different opinion on the matter, and insists the border is exactly where it has been for almost 120 years, and that it is a “settled” issue. The Durand Line was drawn by British officials in the late 19th century.
Afghan officials have been playing up the dispute all weekend, with even the Afghan government’s formal message for the Eid al-Adha holiday bringing up the matter, asking for “unity” to all Afghanistan “particularly to both sides of the Durand Line.” With 120 years of resentment behind the map, this could linger as a diplomatic problem for the US for awhile.
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
Pakistan should also give KP, Punjab, Sindh and Baluchistan to Afghanistan as well. Karzai, however corrupt, would still be a better governor than the current bunch of crooks.
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
^^^ Lol talk about over reaction. What's next handing country over to the Somali pirates?
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
^^^ Lol talk about over reaction. What's next handing country over to the Somali pirates?
Pirates do have a code of honor. So, yes. ;)
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
deleted
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
The buck wont stop at FATA, the demand could include all the area of FATA and KP(including Attock). The Afghans consider Indus as the border, so in short FATA should remain with Pakistan.
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
The whole border between Pakistan and Afghanistan is the Durrand line, and if we hand over the areas that the Afghans consider as theirs we will be left with less than 50 % of the country we have now (effectively Punjab and Sindh). Its about time that the government uses diplomacy to have this issue resolved once for all.
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
pakistan doesn't ''have'' these areas.
Re: Should Pakistan give FATA to Afghans to settle Duran line Issue?
LOL. Wet dream 
Btw why FATA only, because they will be eager to grab Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and a big chunk of Balochistan all together too 
We Pakis should stop being ‘generous’, no issue will be settled by doing so and no Pakistani land should be given to the afghans. Wth. 