Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Sadiyah, There are more sensible reasons to be not part of such a festival than believing that it is a worship of stupid hindu origin ( excuse the language).

Bao Bihari - I get impressed by your copy paste every time i read it. And everytime i feel that something is new but dont know what it is :konfused:

As you seems to have deep interest in origin of festivals in Lahore, kindly enlighten me about the origin of very important festivals in :Lahore known as Mela Charaghaan and ***Mela Mawaishiyaan. *I can give you hints if your have no clue about them :wink:

Your telling me the origin of basant is same as if you see a Pakistani Chirstian friend preparing Christmas tree and you say " Oh, you are decorating your house to celebrate birthday of Qaid-e-Azam !! Great ! how patriotic … "

He would give you a funny look. I hope you get my point :flower1:

(Note :founder of Pakistan was born on 25 dec)

AQ - :biggthumb gud one. but we are hearing this for past many years that we will start celebrating holi from next year.

For God sake please tell us when this next year gona come :mad:

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

:cb:
good one
well hamara dilema yeh hey k hum aik kaam jub ijazet detey hein to uski justifications bhi hazaaar nikaal letey hein
i m not against basant i myself like hala gulla,but its all k jub aik festivity apney sath itna caos laye to there ought to be sum measures taken to c for it
besides yeh kehna k its a non mulim trait being followed by us ,to amaal ka daromadar niyetoo per hota hey if its celebrated as a festival and not for any of the hinuds buzuerg to phir to its al ok i gues i mean all its celbrated is for fun and enjoyment but there should b limits set fot it too

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

pakistanis need some good old pagan fun to break the monotony .

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

lets be banning darts and snooker too..while we are at it :)

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Interestingly enough, I tried looking up the origins and history of Basant and was able to find information that clearly suggests that it started off a religious practice. Islam strictly prohibits us from celebrating any such events and festivals.

Ref: http://www.hindukids.org/stories/festivals/index.html

Ref: Vasant Panchami

Ref: Basant History

Ref: Basant

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Really? Could you please enlighten us as to why is it that darts and snooker should be prohibited? Is there any religious significance attached to either one?

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

^ He is just being an ignorant.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

well theres no form of physical exercise in those either!!!!

lighten up people..people die all the time in sports...that indian guy died in cricket right!!...someone in wrestling...someone in racing!!!

I love kite flying (when i used to )...it shouldnt be banned...my two cents!

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

^
Lets see why Basant Should be banned:

  1. Hindu Festival (Haraam) - I don't need to say more but will continue
  2. Innocent People Die
  3. Property Damage
    Lets Expand on #2 and #3:

  4. The Kite flyer is directly responsible for Death of the Innocent life
    *]The Kite flyer is directly responsible for the Damage to property
    Sports such as Soccer, Hockey, Pool, or Darts - Players are never likely to a be Direct factor for the death (with very few exceptions - and that is due to person mentallity and not the Sport itself).

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

No one is banning kite flying in general. Read carefully and you'll realize it's the Basant festival and not kite flying in itself.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Spring festival is a Hindu festival.
Canada is an ideal Islamic state.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Where is your answer?-even if this is copy paste from 3/4 books that i have specially basant kia hay (you can easily find this book in jamia ashrafia lahore)-
Rather then directly answering the points i raised buss –iran tooran ki kahaniaya :slight_smile:

This is no answer to why basant is not recomended-
mela mawaishiyan kay baray main aap hi behtar bata saktay hain :smiley:

Jazakallah-now i know quais e Azam was founder of pakistan:balley:

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

It's stupid, meaningless and based on a Hindu tradition. And sorry, "fun" is not a good enough excuse to justify the loss of life it causes every year.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

i luv flying a tuqqal!

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

^ Tukkal?

http://images.google.com/images?q=tbn:oSCyln2DozTPAM:www.fly-high.com/drachen/auswahl-EL/piceinleiner/tukkal.JPG

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

spring season is nothing to do with religen. if allah says i send you rain it rains in india/pakistan it dose not stop after pakistann border ends. you all think you own god.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Yep, except thats an ugly one (the picture) bihari sahib… Flying a tuqqal is hard, those that really love their basanti hindu gods can fly this baby.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Sadiyah and Bao bihari,

This is a never ending (periodic) discussion and both parties cant convince each other, hopefully this will be my last post on this topic :flower1:

Briefly ..

I gave the example of Qaid-e-Azam’s birthday which is celebrated every year on Christmass in Pakistan. It is an officail holiday and most govt buildings get decorated …so, an on-looker who does not know the reality may assume that Pakistan officially celebrates Christmas, which is a mistake !

Although Paksitan is celebrating a birthday, but it is not of jesus christ but it is of her founder M A jinnah.

Now, as you are not a native of Lahore, so you can only go to internet to find out what the hell is basant and why crazy lahories celebrate it with so much passion ??

But, sorry. this is not going to help as you people can not understand the importance of kite flying for us. It is a fun activity and a cherished sport. For us it is very serious activity. Having fun is very important for us. To hell with hindu origin, for us it is nothign more than a festival for flying kites and having fun

If having fun is haraam, then Basant is 100% haraam. no doubt

But you cant understand it, you think we are crazy. Maybe you are right !

Just as you and me can not possibly understand the importance of Bull fighgting and what the hell is funny in seeing people getting injured or killed in routine ??? Same way you cant understand the importance of flying kites.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Code Red -- even if it were not a Hindu tradition, it would be still Haram.

[quote]

It is a fun activity and a cherished sport. For us it is very serious activity.
you think we are crazy. Maybe you are right !

[/quote]
Islam asks us to keep a balance

[quote]

Having fun is very important for us.

[/quote]
more than claiming innocent lifes...yes i see your point.

Re: Should Muslims Celebare Basant Festival?

Ok sir :salute:

I have no doubts in your judgement.

:k: