Should Captain have the SAY in selecting Team

??

KARACHI, Aug 8: Pakistan cricket captain Waqar Younis’ outburst
and threat on Tuesday has upset the administrators. According to
highly placed sources, the top hierarchy of the Pakistan Cricket
Board (PCB) contacted manager Yawar Saeed and Waqar Younis to
inquire about their point of views.

Waqar threatened Tuesday that he would quit if the selectors
didn’t give due consideration to his point of view in selection of
the squads…

Full Story

well.......he ahs to captain the team....so i guess his point of view should be taken into consdieration.....but at the end of the day it should still be up to the stupid, ahem sorry the PCB board.

There's a certain amount of "friction" between players and i think that would cause majjor problems within a side chosen by the captain.....doesn't choose those he doesn't like....you would have to trust the captain to be as professional as possible!!!??!!!

i defintely think that he should have some input...suggestions....but leave the selection to the selectors

y2nad

Its the captain who has to dictate the terms when players are in the middle... if he is not happy with the players, how can he guide them to a win??

Imran Khan used to have a big say in selection and made some good winning combinations.. If waqar can do the same.... why not!!???


Zamane kay Andaz Badle Gay
Naya Raag hai, Saaz Badle Gaye

[This message has been edited by CoolHeat (edited August 09, 2001).]

*you would have to trust the captain to be as professional as possible!!!??!!!
*

and why shouldn't we do that?

well ithink captin should have as say but the problem is that politics will b involved as usual

http://www3.pak.org/gupshup/smilies/mad.gif

Waleed dude is right … the problem is not that Skipper being involved or not .. its the dirty politics that comes along .. Skipper should have his say but it should be a limited role .. the purpose of selection process is to identify better of the bunch . and the ways you do it is through identifying and monitoring and analyzing players performance .. not through personal preferences it has to be objective not subjective .. like its done now .. the selection committee members don’t even bother to show up in nets and practice games .. and like Imran Khan was a good example he did his ‘Khalfa-giri’ as well .. players like Shoaib Mohamed Azeem Hafeez suffered at his hands and mediocre players like Mansoor Akhter and Zakir Khan made their way in the national squad.. but it we owe World Cup to Immy’s leadership..


Hey one more thing
These things are hard to explain
For some it seems strange... to swallow
The frontier of our minds
Is the last place we find
But maybe the first place we should go