Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
But there is a valid reason to hate hindus.
Pls elaborate.
Now compare that with the kashmir conflict where more than 100,000 muslims have been killed by the indian army in the last 20 years. Yet in real life or internet i have never come across any indian hindu who does not support india's policy of persecution in kashmir. Even the most liberal indian hindus support their country's policy on kashmir!!
So by that token, should all non-Muslims be hating Muslims because of incidents like 9/11, 26/11 etc. ?
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
Pls elaborate.
So by that token, should all non-Muslims be hating Muslims because of incidents like 9/11, 26/11 etc. ?
There are millions of muslims who condemn what happened on 9/11, 26/11.
But like i said before i have never come across any indian hindu who does not support india's policy of persecution in kashmir. Even the most liberal indian hindus support their country's policy on kashmir!!
Are there any indian hindus who support the kashmiri's right to self-determination??
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
There are millions of muslims who condemn what happened on 9/11, 26/11.
But like i said before i have never come across any indian hindu who does not support india's policy of persecution in kashmir. Even the most liberal indian hindus support their country's policy on kashmir!!
Are there any indian hindus who respect the kashmiri's right to self-determination??
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
^So she is not a Hindu and an atheist.Now you got to find another person(Hindu) for supporting self determination rights of Kahsmiris.But before proceeding to that ask him from which side of kashmir to which side of Kashmir wants that self determination exercise.
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
Pakistan eventually happened through the will of Allah, of course, but that was realised through the Muslim League which, particularly under Jinnah, chose to avoid the path of violent confrontation with the British and worked through constructive dialogue, and indeed cooperation - such as the Muslim League's enthusiastic support for Indian participation in WW2. The Muslim League was able to present itself as a constructive force and have its call for a separate Pakistan taken seriously.
Bhagay Singh and Udham Singh, by contrast, were violent terrorists who deserved what they got.
Jinnah never killed a Brit, nor did he ever call for violence against the British. Jinnah believed in civility and the power of words, and was proven to be correct.
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
Londonistani: You seems to be unaware that not only Hindu's & sikhs killed Muslims, but also Muslims killed Hindus & Sikhs in their hundred thousands. The madness was mutual.
Please google and you will find the truth..
Even the Kashmir case is different than what you may have been taught in Pakistan - It is not a case of 'muslim majority areas become pakistan' - there are a lot of issues involved.
Learn before you come to such discussion boards.
Regarding bhagat Singh & other freedom fighters - they gave their life for freedom of India (& Pakistan). Respect them.
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
I think they should. Granted my knowledge is limited on the subject, but as far as I'm aware they were fighting to get rid of the British. People let this religion stuff go too far. It's all semantics since Indians have the same culture as us anyways. We should feel more allegiance towards fellow desis than Arab countries IMO. A desi political entity like the EU could accomplish so much and to still be fighting over philosophical differences is ignorant.
Ghost first is thing is we dont have the same culture as indians if we had there was no need of getting seprate homeland second thing is if you read books on Bhagat Singh you will find out that is most of his efforts south asians were killed rather than the gora if want to respect Bhagat Singh than why not Taliban
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
whoever Says Quaid E Azam achived his efforts without any blood shed yes there was no bloodshed here butt dont forget you didnt got freedom because of that sir read history carefully even after we passed 1940 Resoulotion British were relaxed and were saying that we are not going to give you independence for next 20 years atleast butt than WORLD WAR 2 started and every one knows what happend to London and other cities of British so they couldnt afford to hold there colonies any more and thus we got freedom
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
[quote=““Zarvan Ali””]
Ghost first is thing is we dont have the same culture as indians if we had there was no need of getting seprate homeland second thing is if you **read books on Bhagat Singh you will find out that is most of his efforts south asians were killed rather than the gora if want to respect Bhagat Singh than why not Taliban/QUOTE]
1)The plight of evident now.
2)You can not compare Bhagat Singh’s actions to Taliban.Taliban is a bunch of criminals who would go to any extreme to achieve their goals.You can’t even call the true Msulims.Taliban’s two of main source of income are extortion and drug trading which both are ,I am sure,condemned and flayed by Islam and true Muslims around the world.
Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?
Mr first Taliban who are fighting in Afghnaistan are not involved in drug trafficking in their goverment drugs production had gone to zero and in most bhagat singh acts south indians were killed so y not call him a terrorist only because a gora killed him doesnt make him a hero
