Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?

[Ghost14]

Re: Should bhagat singh and udham singh be respected by pakistanis?

@Zarvan_Ali

Ghost first is thing is we dont have the same culture as indians if we had there was no need of getting seprate homeland second thing is if you read books on Bhagat Singh you will find out that is most of his efforts south asians were killed rather than the gora if want to respect Bhagat Singh than why not Taliban

As I admitted above, I don’t know much about Bhagat Singh and his activities so I can’t comment on that. As for culture, I disagree. We are the same people, and have lived together for hundreds of years, and besides religion being different, how can you say the cultures are not the same?

Are Indian Muslims the same as Pakistani Muslims? Yes
Are Indian Muslims the same as Indian Hindus? Yes

Therefore, Pakistani Muslims are the same, CULTURALLY, as Hindus. Yes there are some differences, but overall, in terms of how you are to respect your parents, how the family is important etc is the same. Even some customs in Pakistan go against Islam but are remnants of a shared culture with Indians.

Pakistan was created because Jinnah wanted more seats in the Indian government than was reasonable. He expected a Muslim minority to get something like 50% of the seats, which makes no sense. He may just have been using that as an excuse to create a separate country. People who want to paint Jinnah as a saint tend to ignore this side of his character, he’s human and had flaws like everyone else; greed and ambition may have played a part in his actions. These people also ignore that fact that he probably wanted a secular country (not run by Shariah) and that he drank alcohol.

[quote=“Zarvan_Ali”]

@Arleitter

Mr first Taliban who are fighting in Afghnaistan are not involved in drug trafficking in their goverment drugs production had gone to zero and in most bhagat singh acts south indians were killed so y not call him a terrorist only because a gora killed him doesnt make him a hero

Taliban drug trafficking is well reported. Production has not gone down to zero. In fact, extortion of local businesses has also gotten popular. The Taliban are now a business, much like the mafia and since both sides (America and the Taliban) are profiting from the conflict, we probably won’t see an end in the near future.