Well most of sipah-e-sahabah(From sunnis) scholars and most of sunni scholars say that shia’s are not muslims… And shia say that they are on truth and sunnis are not muslims ??? an authentic discussion on this within the parameters of respect would be encouraged. Plz stick to the point and give some hadeez or ayah nothing else to authenticate what you are saying or at least a rwayat from sahaba…
Thank you.
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
Most sunni scholars say shias are muslim. That is why there is no muslim country where shias are not considered to be Muslim.
Contrast that with the situation of Qadiyanis, which is where most sunni scholars did agree that they are non-muslims.
Only a minority amongst sunni scholars maintain that shias are not muslims.
For example. in Pakistan, all the largest sunni Islamic political parties allied with the largest shia Islamic political party to form the MMA.
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
shias are hindus qadiyanis are jews and muslims are christains
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
^ what about Ismailis? I think they're Jews too.
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
sunnis are muslims or not?
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
Any one who says and accepts the Shahada are muslims.
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
i am muslim or not?
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
Shias are muslims.
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
no way...shias r not muslim...they r totally out of the way of islam...raised of shias is the biggest drawback for muslims
Re: Shias are Muslim or not ??
Mad_Scientist has already summed it up.
This thread is bound to cause trouble and within no time we'll have people bashing each other. Plenty has been discussed about Shias and their beliefs in the past. Please use the search option to locate those threads, as they might be of assistance to you.