Shia:Is It Permitted To Believe That Ali Ra Is God?

[Das_Reich]

Re: Shia:Is It Permitted To Believe That Ali Ra Is God?

@smooth_guy

^Exactly.

There had been loads of crap said in early Shia books as well about the ideology of Imamiyat. Some even takes it beyond Prophethood. Even to prove divinity of Imams, the writers go beyond sanity and claim that they don’t born through birth canal but from the thighs of their mothers. Piece of Garbage. Those pure souls are free of any filth associated with them. They were human beings just like Prophet SAW himself, Ahle Bait and Sahaba.

I don’t think majority of Shia believe in those factitious and baseless claims. Eventhough they are said to be the saying of Imams, but any sane person would know that they are made up statements.

Salam
Thats more close to reality brother, a good academic book to study early extremist shia beliefs would be “Extremist shia” by Matti Moosa.Later when the imami doctrine was formulated by the pupils of Jafir as Sadiq many such extremist beliefs were edited out but several of them reemerged in a more sanitized version under the safavid revival and were enshirned by their scholars like Baqir Majlisi.