Shia brothers please answer: Why would Umar/Uthman R.A compile Quran?

[Janjua39]

Re: Shia brothers please answer: Why would Umar/Uthman R.A compile Quran?

@aqeel123

Yep shia beleive is that Quran was complete and in form of a book bfr Holy Prophet s.a.w left the world.

1.** If there was no written quran then what did HAffiz’s have memorized ? To memorize a book you need to have a book.**
2. If there was no book Umar bin khitaab wudnt have said “Book of ALLAH is enough for us”
3. “Today I have perfected your religion and completed my favour upon you, and I was satisfied that Islam be your religion.” (Qur’an 5:3). Islam is incomplete without Quran.

you are telling the world that you have to have a book to able to memorize?