Re: Shia And Sunni Muslims
Shia all great scholars wrote books that talk about the changing..deletion and incompleteness of quran.....
SHIAS GREAT BOOKS ABOUT CHANGING .... INCOMPLETENESS....DELETED QURAN
1.Kitab Tahreef Ahmed Bin Muhammad Bin Khalid Albarqi
2.and Tusi **mentioned it in its book **Alfahrist
3.his father Muhammad bin khalid barqi wrote a book Kiab Tanzeel wal Taghayyar
4.and greatest shia asma rajjal scholar Najashi mentioned in its book.
5.Kitab AlTanzeel Min Quran Wal Tahreef *Ali Bin Fazzal *
*wrote a book...and shias claim that he never mistake in ahadees *
6.Kitab AlTahreef wal Tabdeel Muhammad bin Hassan sarifi
7.Kitaab ul Qirrat Ajhmed Bin Muhammad Bin Sayyar he is the teacher of great shia scholar and mufaasir Ibnel Mahyar
and mentioned in Al_fahrist and Rijal Najashi
8.AlTanzeel wal Tahreef Hassan bin Sulaiman Al Hilli
9.Qirrat Momieen wal Qiraat Ahle Bait Babun AlHajjam
10.Qiratt Momineen Abu Tahir Abdul Wahid Qumi
11.Ibne shair Ashooab mentioned it in its book Maualim Ulema
12.Saad Saod Ibne Taous
13.Kitab Tafseer Quran wal Tawiil Tanzeel
14.Qirrat Rasool wal Ahle Bait
15.Kitab AAl Siyyari
these were all great old age scholars of shias
now lets look at the present age shia scholars who wrote books on "alternation" of quran
16.fasalul Khitaab .Fe Isbaat Tehreef kitaab Mirza Muhammad Noori Tabrasi....(already mentiod above post)
17.Radee Shubhaat aan Fsil ALl khitaab
18.Tasheef Katbain wa Naqse Ayaat Kitab Mubeen Mirza Sultan Ahmed Dehlvi
19.Zarbat-e-Haidria Syed Muhammad Mujtahid Luknawi
these were complete books ...now lets see whats scholars give "chapters on alternations of Quran".........
1.Tafseer of Ali Bin Ibraheem Qumi
2.Asool Kafi by Kalini (bukhari of shia)
3.Sharah al -Wafia by Muhammad Kazmi
4.Basaair Darjaat by Shiekh Safa
5.Nashkul quran wa Manshookha by Saad bin Abdullah
in all these chapters is written that no one has complete quran excepts the imams...ayats have been changed and lost...
*The list of those Sahaba and Tabe’in who testified (in Sunni books) about mistakes in the Quran compiled by Uthman *
1. Ayesha
2. Hafsah
3. Umar
4. Ibn Umar
5. Uthman bin Affan
6. Aban bin Uthman
7. Ibn Abbas
8. Abu Musa al-Ash'ari
9. Ubai bin Ka`b
10. Abdullah Ibn Masud
11. Abu Muawyah
12. Urwah bin Zubair
13. Hasham bin Umro
14. Harun bin Musa
15. Zubair bin al Harees
16. Akramah
17. Abdullah
18. Yahyah bin Abu Bashir
19. Saeed bin Jubair
20. Ismail Makki
21. Qatadah
22. Hassan Basri
23. Ubaid bin Zuhaak
24. Mujahid
The list of those Sunni Scholars who have stated,recorded or have endorsed the traditions which shows distortion in Quran
1. Al Hafid Imam Jalaluddin Suyuti
2. Imam Bukhari
3. Imam Muslim
4. Abu Daud
5. Ibn Hazm
6. Imam Hakim
7. Imam Dhahabi
8. Imam Ahmed
9. Ibn Kathir
10. Ibn Hajar Asqalani
11. Imam Behaqi
12. Qurtubi
13. Abi Bakar Sajistani
14. Baghwi
15. Imam Fakhruddin Razi
16. Ibn Jarir Tabari
17. Imam Shokani
18. Badruddin A`ini
19. Allamah Anwar Shah Kashmiri
20. Allamah Abdul Wahab Sherani
21. Raghib Asfahani
22. Allamah Qazi Thanaullah Pani Patti
23. Imam Abu Hanifa
24. Imam Auzai
25. Imam Malik
26. Dr. Israr Ahmed