Re: Shia And Sunni Muslims
No, rather you have been providing the ‘reasons’ and excuses regarding Ibn Masud rejecting two surah of Quran. Main wajah nehen pooch raha, I am just pointing out the fact that a Sahabi didnt believe two complete surah to be the part of Quran hence he rejected them to write in his mushaf. So his case is same as to those of the Shia traditions. If a Sahabi can reject two Surahs and still be a Muslim then Nawasib have no right to yapp at Shia traditions (again, noone is interested in the reasons).
yes, I had previously cited 4-5 famed Sunni Tafseers according to which the very Ibn Masud used to read the name of Ali [as], in the verse of Maidah.
All those Shia traditions are not saying that those words were the part of Quran, rather for god sake understand this, when verses used to reveal, some explainatory stuff also used to reveal, the names of sahaba, kufaars etc are the part of those explainatory stuff, not the part of actual ayats. So even if those were not written down by your kingpins, it doesnt make any difference in respect of the completeness of Quran, we just have lost some extra knowledge thats it.
Please insert this belief of Shias in your mind, and I hope I will not have to repeat myself in future.
Yes, according to a companion and the lover of Yazeed [la], i.e. Abdullah Ibn Umar, most of the Quran has been lost.
“Ibn Umar said: Verily among you people one would say that he has found Quran while he does not how much the total quantity of Quran was because most of the Quran has been lost rather one should say that verily he has found the Quran which has been made available."
- Tafseer Dur e Manthur by Imam Jalaluddin Suyuti, Volume 1 page 106
- Tafseer Al Itqan (Urdu), by Imam Jalaluddin Suyuti, Volume 2 page 64
- Tafseer Ruh al Mani, Volume 1 page 25
5
Everyone counts ayats in his own matter, if the difference of opinions regarding the number of verses makeso ne kaafir then there are same kind of references in Sunni text as well. Just start giving fatwa agasint the following sunni scholars. For example:
Allamah Jalaluddin Suyuti has recorded a tradition from Ibn Abbas[ra] wherein he says:
“The number of verses in Quran is 6616”
Tafseer Al Itqan fi Uloom al Quran, Volume 1 page 84
Imam Jalaluddin Suyuti while mentioning the views of Abu Umar Daani about Quran writes:
“Daani states that there is consensus and ijma over 6000 verses in Quran”
Al Itqan fi Uloom al Quran, Volume 1 page 84
So according to Sunni sources, Imam Ahle Sunnah Abu Umar Daani was rejecter of 666 verses of Quran.
Thus, as I said, different people have different manner of counting verses. Thats what your own sorcues say**:**
“The total number of verses in Quran is 6000 and there is disagreement about the rest of the verses and there are various views and statements about them. One statement is that there are 6204 verses”
- Tafseer Ibn Kathir, Volume 1 page 7, number of verses
- Tafseer Qurtubi, Volume 1 page 65, number of verses
Caliph Umar’s belief that Quran had ninety Parahs; 700369 letters are missing
We read in Al Itqan fi Uloom al Quran:
"Hadhrath Umar said that the Qur’an have 1,027,000 letters and whoever will read them with the intention of earning reward [Thawab], he will he will earn one woman from Hoors of paradise against each letter. All the narrators of this tradition are Thiqah”.
- Kanz al Umaal, Volume 1 page 135 Hadith 2308 (Online Link)
- Al Itqan, fi Uloom al Quran Volume 1 page 88 by Jalaluddin Suyuti
- Jama` al-Sagheer, Volume 2 page 88, Chapter: alif laam
According to Ibn Abbas, the present Quran contain 326631 letters, which means according to Umar, 700369 letters are missing from the present Quran which ultimately means that the number of letters in the present Quran have to be thrice its present amount in order to comply with the statement of Umar, but in that case the number of Parahs would hop up to ninety.
etc etc… Also according to Ubai, Ayesha and Umar, Surah Taubah was more than or equal to Surah baqra, that means they believed that 127 verses has been lost from Surah Taubah.
Again, those words were not the actual verses rather ‘explainatory’ stuff. And as i said above, according to authentic Sunni souces, your sweet sweet Sahabi Ibn Masud also believed in the verse of wilayat/Maulayat.
Because they all believed in different wordings of Quran. You have been sayingthat one who believes decrees, addition or mistake in Quran is Kaafir, then the people whom I have listed are ones who believed in different words of Quran, somesaid, it should have been this not that, some said that fulan fulan word in Quran is incorrect etc. So you got it as to why I am bringing their names?
I already have cited examples of some of those in the list, if you want to see more samples, then jsut tell me whose shall i shoe you ![]()
Thanx, as i said, all those people i have listed believed in tahreef of one form or other. They were all busy in bringing their own text and claim to be the part of Quran.