^ , for u anything islamic is a stupid idea. why do u even bother contributing to the threads that doesnt concern u or ur saath pushtay?
why would anyone want khilafat in canada? no one has been implement that in any muslim countries itself. the point is that some of the muslims would like to deal with Domestic problems according to islam, just like jews are able to do it and like christians are able to do it and so are other religions able to do it. it is being implemented while considering the fundemental rights of average canadians as per the charter and the law of canada. if anything conflicts with the charter, the decision will be revoked. thats the whole point and further it is not being 'forced' upon anyone. no one is being stoned to death or forced to eat anything they dont want to.
yes you can only implement social governance per shariah, but not criminal and political governance. those who seek to submit themselves to a shariah law will accept and abide. which is what Hindus and Jews often used to have during Muslim governments in arabia and elsewhere, rulings based on their own religion within a Muslim government.
no. firstly a vast minority of Muslims even believes a Khilafa in canada is desirable, regardless of how much you wish to negelect the majority view, and focus on the minority idiocy. seeing your track record, it isnt surprising to see you sieze on the more ludicrous of views.
no, i’ll tell you why. its because we dont believe that Khilafa needs to be established in a country where Muslims are migrants. And heres the Islamic basis for that einstein. The Prophet gave Muslims injunctions during his life to seek a life in a Christian country under a Christian king living under the laws of the land, and a fair number of them settled there too. Practicing Islam and whatever shariah laws possible WHILE being in a christian country, under a christian king.
try to get educated about the religion before you try and speak about our intentions.
Well, the Ontario government has said NO to using using Shariah law in marriage arbitration, and has ruled that Christians, Jews, and Ismailis will now lose the right to use their religious laws in arbitration as well.
^
that sux. why do jews and christians have to lose the right? for christians this is their country. for jews, they are loving caring people who donot discriminate against their women. ismailis, i don’t know much but i know their girls are pretty hot :D. not to allow muslims to use their shariah law is perfectly right. they have more rights for animals than for their women.
Ravi:Canada is not a christian country. It is a secular one. It has christian originations but it is not a christian country. Secular laws prevail over religious ones. Most of the world doesn't think in terms of religon first, it is a islamic malady.
The fact that muhammad gave an injunction in the 7th century about living in christian country under a christian king has no prevalence in today's world. Is it just christian? what about buddhist? SHinto? Secular...which is really pagan because no interpretation of God is more or less valid than another.
_Ca02: I am making the same point. That secular laws will take precendent over religous ones, God's laws that are not in conformity with man's laws will be discarded. Man is smarter than God.
Pinstripe: Why must you be such a literalist? That will land you in a lot of trouble, and you will insist on travelling only on camel.
A lot of Islamic laws today are based on extrapolations from rulings of the Prophet in similar but not the same situations. While najashi was Christian, the reason for Ethiopia as a country to migrate to was that he was a benevolent ruler who would allow Muslims to seek refuge there and practice their religion. The same reasoning would apply to buddhist, shinto and secular governments.
By the way, Islamically Muslims are supposed to abide by the law of the land while abiding by their religion, and if the former makes the latter impossible, they're not supposed to establish Khilafa, they're supposed to move.
true, but so does lot of influential muslims in Ontario. it will be interesting to track the progress of this issue though. let see canadian government akhir kitnay pani mein hai.
I believe Muslims in canada must be given right to practice sharia law. As jews and christians of this country are allowed to practice as democratic free society.
