Shallum Xavier talks about the `bleak relevance'of Pakistan `nationhood'.

shallum

Just see how one of the best musicians in Pakistan expresses his concern over increasingly becoming `Talibanisation' of Pakistan.

Re: Shallum Xavier talks about the bleak relevance'of Pakistannationhood'.

and his feelings represnt the resentiments of Pak minorities.........

So you are one of those minorities he is talking about?

Which part of Pakistan are you from?

Re: Shallum Xavier talks about the bleak relevance'of Pakistannationhood'.

^You need not ask all these questions in an open forum like this.

Madam you are making a statement in an open forum about Minorities, one has assume you are one of the Minorities ,can you back it up.............what are you afraid of admitting?

That you are from Hindustan?

need not be shy about your homeland...............your statements reveal clearly where you are from................:)

Re: Shallum Xavier talks about the bleak relevance'of Pakistannationhood'.

Now that you have changed my gender also. :p

I can fight for religious minorities of Pakistan and it is my choice.But revealing my identity is something different.Pls do not read between lines.

Now pls let the thread to go on and do not bring in off-the topic conversations.

minorities?? he dated with a muslim girl A TV VJ (best of my knowledge), he has such a large base of admirers ,can perform anywhere where others can and you still talk of minority thing...

whatever it is good or worst in pakistan is for all and everyone going through, bringing the veil of minority in it is like asking for special treatment.

Re: Shallum Xavier talks about the bleak relevance'of Pakistannationhood'.

Firstly, arleitter, you stated elsewhere you are Indian didnt you, so its my job to educate you about Pakistan? Secondly, Shallaoum has all the freedom in the world. He is attending those silly 'wannabe' parties in Karachi pretty much everyday, and as a Christian has a license to buy alcohol if he pleases, practices music, goes to church (he does, I knwo for a fact). He has made a decent name for himself and is quite a talented musician. You would be shocked if you see some of his pictures on facebook, which speak ALOT about the freedom hes enjoying in Pakistan.