Re: Shajra-e-mal`oona
Brother DanishJu – Please read my post again. I have not expressed any opinion of mine own. Like all Muslims I hold opinions of Ibn Abbas, Masruq, Abu Malik, Al-Hasan Al-Basri and others mentioned in my post to be believed as the truth and to be followed.
They hold Shajra-e-maloona refers to Tree of Zaqqum and that sufficed for me.
Sorry, your opinions are mere sectarian inspired speculations.
[QUOTE]
This was narrated by Ibn `Abbas, Masruq, Abu Malik, Al-Hasan Al-Basri and others. Everyone who interpreted the Ayah to refer to the Night of the Isra', also interpreted it to refer to the Tree of Zaqqum.
[/QUOTE]
and you said:
[QUOTE]
I hope you also consider these discussions as accadamic with the intention to find the truth only.
[/QUOTE]
And that is my intention too but I follow the opinions of Scholars of repute than my own.