You need to choose one of them for the only open spot left for an all-rounder,
Assuming both are fit and have match practice, which one would you choose?
Shahid Afridi | Cricket Players and Officials | Cricinfo.com
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
1.afridi for ODI
2.Razzaq for Test
3.Afridi for t20
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
razzaq for all formats
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
none of them...hammaz adam is da man
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
I dont agree with the notion that Razzaq should captain, i dont see him as a solid choice. Afridi is a much better character for a captain and if there is one other person i would consider (but is really out of form) is MISBAH, i know a lot of ppl will disagree but seriously if there is anyone in the team who can lead other than Afridi its him.
lets just see
Salman Butt - No way
Imran Farhat - hell no 
Misbah - may be
Umar Akmal - bilkul nahi
kamran akmal - mein cricket dekhna chhordoonga
Afridi - Definately
Razzaq - i dont see him as a captain
umar gul - lets keep him away from this politics
Mohammad Amer - same as gul
Mohammed Asif - banda is a thinking cricketer lekin reputation achee nahi hai harkaton kee wajah sey
Shoaib Akhtar - 
Fawad Alam - woh to shukar kar raha hoga key ab regular khelney ka mauqa milega 
Tell me if i am wrong :k:
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
afridi dont even deserve to be in the team, captain. yeh rite 
reality is we dont have a captain in this team. Dont under estimate Razzaq, he might not be very vocal on the field but he has a good cricketing brain and he can be a role model for the team with his performance. He can ball bat and field as well. In any format there are better chances of razzaq scoring some runs and ball good than afridi.
AFRIDI cannot be trusted with the bat or ball
u got a kidding me …Afridi deserves the captaincy …at least he plays for the team unless razzaq when not selected goes to ICL …
i agree razzaq is better than afridi in batting but not certainly in bowling
razzaq is gona be a yousuf like captain im sure about that
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
^ I personally think, Afridi is also a politician who got off cheaply in this mess. In fact he was most vocal in getting captaincy even when there was no vacant place....
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
Guys... the discussion was for an 'all-rounder' and not a 'captain' :)
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
lol…razzaq…
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
^^
hehehhe 
razzaq is a pathetic fielder
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
Afridi brings aggression to the team.. :k:
Razzak brings aggression to batting only.. 
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
i tell you what afridi brings
DISAPPOINTMENT and HUMILITY !!!
same guys like u were chanting his name when he won the world cup for us
zada jazbati batain na karo larkay 
disappointment is when a player gives away his loyalty for dollars..
i dont know if Afridi did dat 
Re: Shahid Afridi or Abdul Razzaq?
zobia that wasnt razzaq!
afridi in all formats. his bowling is so much better than razzaq's and batting wise they're about even.
The only problem of not making Afridi captain is that he wont give 100 % in teh field - and making him one is that there is no guarantee that he wont start chewing the ball - he is a certified idiot
that’s not even razzaq, the fielder is rana naveed the bowler is razzaq
and he also bring ball eating to the team hahaha. but still my favourite player 
The only problem of not making Afridi captain is that he wont give 100 % in teh field - and making him one is that there is no guarantee that he wont start chewing the ball - he is a certified idiot
great point. this is exactly what he did in the RBS T20 semifinal.
and no player who won't give his 100% when he's not captain should be ever selected to play for Pakistan - forget about making him captain.