serving alcohol

Peace Seminole

The hadith have been around since during the life of Muhammad (SAW), it was the grouping and classification of hadith that took place many years later. You can actually read some hadith where someone had quoted somone who has quoted the prophet (SAW) because he was there.

As for the money linked with the sale of wine it only applies to the direct supply chain and not the state generated income from it, because those benefitting from that are totally unaware of it and cannot be held accountable. Look at all those people who are mentioned in the hadith they all are inherently in positions where they must know what they are doing. On another level state money when distributed cleanses where it has come from.

When money is given in charity it is cleansed.