Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

Society Religion & Philosophy
1

This is what Ghazali said:

“Thus the entirety of the jurist’s competence is tied to the profane world.”
Ihya ulum al-din at 30.

How much longer before the Salafi/Wahhabi/Taliban fanatics condemn Ghazali as an apostate? lol

2

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

You want to elaborate on this? Or are you just pulling some other person's words? The words of Ali Eteraz maybe? Or are you Ali Eteraz?

3

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

He is a nobody...Let him rattle his own cage...

4

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

Forgot to post a link, thanks for bringing that to my attention.

http://eteraz.wordpress.com/2007/09/19/ghazali-agrees-with-ali-eteraz/

Don’t hate that Ali Eteraz is smarter than you.

5

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

Kinda like yourself? No one cares what a fake wannabe backward e-jihadi clown such as yourself thinks.

Go back to Bakistan, loser.

6

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

Imam Ghazali is not infalliable ....but there is NO seperation of religion and state in Islam

7

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

If religion is being manipulated and taught ineffectively and with mistakes and if wrong things are being perpetuated in the name of Islam, then you do NEED to separate religion and state in today's world.

If the world were an ideal Islamic world, your words hold true. But it isn't a real world. Wake up and smell the ridiculous behavior going on in the world in the name of Islam around you.

8

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

??? that's why we have Islam, to make this world an Islamic world..

9

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

excatly....agreed...friend how are you..its been long ..i am talking to you on forum ...:)

10

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

How can he know you?

What does one do
11

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

Dear PCG...the fault is in teaching the interpreation in wrong way....not in islam or stae..its the similar ..if you have a headache..you cut the head....
if wrong things are added in name of islam..llike we see in taliban's afgahnistan and pakistani tribal ara ruling ..its not means that the whole pakistan will be declared as SECULAR....

the cure of certain problem is the best solution..and without religion the state is nothing..just jungle rule ..in social lives of people....as we see in West...

[quote]
If the world were an ideal Islamic world, your words hold true. But it isn't a real world. Wake up and smell the ridiculous behavior going on in the world in the name of Islam around you.
[/quote]

12

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

because he has promissed me to ahve** "Nargasi Kauftai"** at his walima ceremony for me....and i am waiting for that moment ...:)

13

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

And how and who decides which is the right version of Islamic system?

14

Re: Seperation of mosque and state by a traditionalist

^^ Sir how are you..how the life going in Gulf ?

actually ..difference of opinons in all great faqeehs of ilam..nothing matters at all...its itention of any individual which matters.....a famous hadeeth ..rather first of every hadees book..tat amal depends upon niyaat....

following anyone with good intention matters nothing ..all are correct....

you are Lahori....:) so you know that to reach Old Anarkali Food Street ..there are 4 ways....

from Punjab secretariat ....
from Neela Gumbad
from Mall road
from AG office...

ways are different ..but you will reach the same destination....

similar is the case here...:)