from the title one can understand that this must be an anti-Pakistani post, and you are right it is but writen by an indian. Good to bring it here on, lets see how many Pashtun feel those SCRATCHES, by theway i dont feel any SCRATCH happy to be a Pakistani, i am for a permanent boarder.
Re: SCRATCHED across Pashtun hearts!
Same scratch was done by brits in the name of Red Cliff ( whatever the spellings are) by dividing Punjab and giving access to what he call today INDIA to the state of Kashmir...
Scratches are there all over the body of ASIA, but Indian who want to see Pakistan de-stablize just come up these kind of articles... these are the very same Indians who have killed over 100,000 people in Kashmir, and is busy killing in Assaam and other parts, forcing those states to stay united with India, before pointing fingers on others, India should clear its very own scratches, ofcourse Indians dare not to talk about it...
Re: SCRATCHED across Pashtun hearts!
afghanistan has never been a truely seperate nation to pakistan, lets just officially recognise it as a province
Pakistan has never been a truely seperate nation to hindustan, lets just officially recognise it as a state...
Given that the enlightened degeneration of the past decade has brought the citizens of Pakistan ever closer in culture, rituals and faith with their mostly hindu indian counterparts...
Re: SCRATCHED across Pashtun hearts!
although many tribes r divided into two across durand but they hav no problem in crossing and communication with each other.
pakistan has readjusted its border with iran and china then why not afghanistan?
The boundaries of those countries including Pakistan, India, Iran and Afghanistan need re-evaluation based on common languages and cultures. Once these new counties develop their identities and nationhood then they should form a union similar to EU based on mutual respect and equality.
And by the way, that’s what is the plan for that region.
you seem to have cut every country up according to linguistic/ethnic groups except afghanistan.
afghanistan would lose much of its western and northern territory as its predominantly persian/tajik/uzbek.
i can understand you adding the pashtun territories of pakistan to that afghanistan in the map but you have added chitral, the northern areas and hazara to - lol!
that map of afghanistan would look very different under your plan you would lose kabul as a capital city as its primarily persian speaking.
you seem to have cut every country up according to linguistic/ethnic groups except afghanistan.
afghanistan would lose much of its western and northern territory as its predominantly persian/tajik/uzbek.
i can understand you adding the pashtun territories of pakistan to that afghanistan in the map but you have added chitral, the northern areas and hazara to - lol!
that map of afghanistan would look very different under your plan you would lose kabul as a capital city as its primarily persian speaking.
This is not my map or not my plan, this map was published by Ralph Peter in Armed Forces Journal in article 'Blood borders" .
Anyway, if you look at the map you will see that Afghanistan will also lose it's western city Herat to Iran.
This is not my map or not my plan, this map was published by Ralph Peter in Armed Forces Journal in article 'Blood borders" .
Anyway, if you look at the map you will see that Afghanistan will also lose it's western city Herat to Iran.
Ralph got one more thing wrong. No way in hell would Sindh be part of this pseudo pakistan, comprising mostly of Punjab. Anyway, it's a map from one analyst's brain, and not very accurate.
Ralph got one more thing wrong. No way in hell would Sindh be part of this pseudo pakistan, comprising mostly of Punjab. Anyway, it's a map from one analyst's brain, and not very accurate.
I agree! Sindhis have different language and culture than Punjabis. They definitely qualify to be a Nation.
I agree! Sindhis have different language and culture than Punjabis. They definitely qualify to be a Nation.
linguisticaly they may b different but not racialy so much.
Given that the enlightened degeneration of the past decade has brought the citizens of Pakistan ever closer in culture, rituals and faith with their mostly hindu indian counterparts...
very true and very interesting
would you give up this opportunity to unite our pashtuns?