Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Pakistan’s Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif to be charged under 104-year-old corruption law

          ** The three Pakistanis at the centre of the spot-fixing scandal are likely to be    charged under a 104-year-old corruption law after a landmark ruling by the    Attorney General.   **

By Richard Edwards, Crime Correspondent

*The Telegraph *can disclose there is a “strong appetite” to prosecute Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir, according to legal and police sources.

It comes after another cricketer accused of similar claims has been charged under the rarely-used corruption law, and for cheating under the new Gambling Act.

The Attorney General rubber-stamped the decision to prosecute former Essex seamer Mervyn Westfield for deliberately bowling badly during a one-day game against Durham. Sources said that it paved the way for charges against the Pakistan cricketers.

Scotland Yard detectives interviewed them in September on suspicion of defrauding bookmakers after a newspaper sting alleged they received orders from businessman Mazhar Majeed to deliberately bowl no-balls in the Lord’s Test against England.
Police are now pursuing a charge of “accepting or obtaining corrupt payments” contrary to their “employer’s affairs or considerations” under the 1906 Corruption Act. It was originally framed for those working in public office and carries a maximum penalty of seven years in jail.
In the News of the World sting, Majeed, an agent, received £150,000 from an undercover reporter. It is understood that detectives have recovered just £4,000 of the money.
Two files of evidence have been passed by police to the Crown Prosecution Service, whose lawyers are under pressure to make a decision on any charges ahead of the February’s World Cup, which is being held in India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.
They will now be able to refer to the precedent set by Dominic Grieve, the Attorney General, in the Westfield case - making charges more likely.
Westfield was originally charged with conspiracy to defraud after an investigation into a match against Durham in September 2009.
His lawyers argued that the case was not legitimate because the accusations did not fit the law.
It was also difficult to establish a potential “victim” in the case because no legal bookmaker in Britain actually takes bets on the timing of specific no-balls or wides, At an Old Bailey hearing last month, David Durose, prosecuting, said that the matter had been referred to the Attorney General to approve “more suitable” charges.
The first charge is under the corruption law and the second count is cheating under the Gambling Act 2005.
*The Telegraph *has learnt that the chief legal adviser agreed to an indictment with two new charges.
A CPS spokesperson said: “The CPS has decided that Mervyn Westfield should be charged with corruptly accepting or obtaining a payment for himself and with assisting another to cheat at gambling. Both charges relate to bowling in a manner calculated and intended to allow the scoring of runs in a NatWest Pro40 cricket match.
“We will not proceed with the charge of conspiracy to defraud as we have decided that the two new charges better fit the facts of the case. There was no substantial legal argument on the previous charge and the decision to replace it with the new charges was taken by the CPS.”

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

I hope they do and let the court bring otu everything in open, something which ICC doesnt seem to be doing.

And i hope after the trial we can get over and done with the matter and get on with cricket.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

THE CPS and the british police in general seem to be pretty lousy and slow - even the imran farooq case is still up in the air. And this one has been up in the air for too long. In my view they are as bound by red tape as Pakistani/indian police...they may have latest technologies in forensics, etc. but they are not agile / swift in action. British laws are probably hindering their movement.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Chalain ye din bhi dekh lengay.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

ICC chief vows firm action against suspended trio dated

DUBAI: Chief executive Haroon Lorgat insists the International Cricket Council will deal firmly with the Pakistan players facing spot-fixing charges should they be found guilty.

Seamers Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir and previous Test captain Salman Butt will have their hearings in front of an ICC Anti-Corruption Tribunal in January. They are currently suspended due to charges relating to the fourth Test against England in the summer.

Lorgat told BBC Radio Five Live: “We would want to be proportional but at the same time we do not want to show any leniency. These are severe issues and integrity of the game is absolutely fundamental and we would not want to tolerate any of that in sport.”

He added: “My understanding is that any matter that we decide on in a disciplinary process is always open to contest in the Court of Arbitration for Sport.”

Michael Beloff QC will chair the full hearing against the trio which is scheduled for January 6-11 in Doha.

Joining Beloff on the tribunal will be fellow code of conduct commissioners Justice Albie Sachs of South Africa and Kenya’s Sharad Rao and Lorgat is confident of the strength of the case that has been brought by the ICC.

“I am quite satisfied with the three judges we have managed to secure,” Lorgat added.

"We’ve worked hard at collecting all the evidence that we would require to make the charges stand.

“I’m confident that our guys have worked very hard in ensuring they have got a case they can present which should stand the test of scrutiny.”

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Salman Butts lawyer hits out at ICC official

KARACHI: The lawyer for suspended former Pakistan captain Salman Butt on Saturday lashed out at a top cricket official who said he would be “disappointed” if players in a spot-fixing case were acquitted.

Butt is facing an International Cricket Council (ICC) tribunal along with pace bowlers Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Aamer over allegations of spot-fixing in the series against England earlier this year.

ICC chief executive Haroon Lorgat told the BBC he was confident of the case against the players.

“We need to send out a strong message and that is part of what we want to achieve,” Lorgat said.

“We’ve worked hard at collecting all the evidence that we would require to make the charges stand. I am confident that our guys have worked very hard in ensuring they have got a case they can present which should stand the test of scrutiny.”

The ICC provisionally suspended the three players in September following reports in British tabloid News of the World which claimed Pakistani players, including the suspended trio, took money to carry out orders from a bookmaker at specific stages in the Lord’s Test in August.

Butt and Aamer lost their appeals against the suspension last month, while Asif withdrew after initially deciding to challenge the sanction.

The ICC tribunal, led by code of conduct commissioner Michael Beloff, will hear the case in Doha, Qatar from January 6 to 11. The two other members are Sharad Rao and Albie Sachs.

Butt’s lawyer Khalid Ranjha said Lorgat’s comments were a “threat to the tribunal.”

“What Lorgat has said is tantamount to threatening the prospective tribunal,” Ranjha, a former Pakistani law minister, told AFP from Lahore.

“The ICC wants the judges to give a decision on dotted lines and this is not a good example set by the ICC official.”

Ranjha, who also represented Butt in his unsuccessful appeal hearing, said he believed ICC was trying to pressure the players into boycotting the tribunal.

The fixing scandal deepened on Wednesday when Pakistani television station Geo broadcast footage apparently showing bookmaker Mazhar Majeed implicating another four Pakistan players during the England tour.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

I don’t think SALMON should be excused but why oh why is LORGAT going on the offensive and trying to influence the TRIBUNAL in such a way…so much for the independence of it…
:smack:

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

n today lorgat said that If they r guilty they cannot appeal

i knew it ICC wants to finish cricket from Pakistan

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

There are hardly any good teams these days. How is the world cricket a better place without Pakistan? Exclusion of Pakistan is not good for business either. People don't prefer Ireland and Canada over Pakistan.

It is time we own some of our issues too.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

But why the hell ICC is talking against Pakistan so much

Look at that Lorgat

i thought he was a sensible man

he had no right to say that i want these cricketers to be banned

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

How is banning satay baaz finshing cricket form Pakistan. It was these satay baaz who have done untold damage to cricket in Pakistan. Shame on these guys who sold their country for ££'s. Apart from Aamir the other two are no loss for Pakistan cricket.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

They can appeal in the Sports arbitration court and to be honest, if they were smart, that’s what they would make their counter statement to Lorgat’s press release that “If ICC does not make a new Neutral Tribunal then we will prepare our case for the Court of Arbitration”. http://www.tas-cas.org/news

Not that I want to give SALMON any real ideas :smiley:

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Agree with u we need Amir back

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Ehsan bhai is criticizing Lorgat - about time ehsan bhai…:smiley:

http://cricket.ndtv.com/storypage.aspx?id=SPOEN20100162476&nid=71103

Lorgat’s comments on spot-fixing inappropriate: Mani
Press Trust of India
07 December 2010 (Karachi)

ICC CEO Haroon Lorgat’s statement that he would be disappointed if Pakistani cricketers implicated in the spot-fixing scandal are found not guilty has miffed the governing body’s former President Ehsan Mani, who feels the remark was inappropriate.

Mani said the case was yet to be heard by the ICC code of conduct tribunal and Lorgat’s statement was not required and unnecessary.

“The three-member ICC tribunal will hold the hearing next month, therefore Lorgat should not have said anything on the issue, his (Lorgat’s) remarks were inappropriate and if I was the ICC president, I would surely take action against him”, said Ehsan Mani told the ‘News One’ channel.

Lorgat has also upset the lawyers based for the three suspended players, Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir.

The trio will attend a hearing from January 6 to 11 in Doha regarding the various charges levelled against them by the ICC anti-corruption and security unit.

Mani also hit out at the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) and said the way the PCB had given a cold shoulder to the trio was inexplicable.

“I would think the PCB should have stood by the three players until they were proven guilty,” he said.

But Tafazzul Rizvi, the legal advisor of the PCB made it clear he didn’t believe Lorgat’s statement was uncalled for or inappropriate.

“One must not forget that he is also the ICC chief executive and the ICC is the party pressing the charges against the player in this case so Lorgat has every right to say he would be disappointed if the players were not found guilty,” Rizvi said.

He also pointed out that the PCB would not have anything to do with the case since the ICC had charged the three players individually and they had to respond themselves.

“The PCB is not a party in this case and cannot be seen as getting involved with the players or supporting them in any manner,” he said.

Mani, meanwhile, also questioned the PCB’s policy of quietly sidelining some senior players from the national team including Kamran Akmal, Danish Kaneria and Shoaib Malik.

“To me it appears as if the PCB is dancing to the tune of others,” he added.

“The PCB first terminated their contracts and then pulled back the legal support too, no organisation does this to it’s employees. Also the manner in which a few more players were quietly sidelined is also dubious. I feel that the PCB has no control over the issue and it is only acting on external instructions”, said Mani, who headed the ICC between 2003 and 2006.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

I have been supporting these players all along, I dont beleive they Players r totally innocent but i alss believe that ICC has pre planned everything.

I think BCCI has a problem with Pakistani players playing in India. First they found excuses to exclude them from IPL, ICL is over for good. Now they have set up the format in a way that if a home team qualifies for knockouts they will play at home. The only question now is what if Pakistan some how manages to get into finals ? Final will be played in India... and the answer is: "lets make sure Pakistan doesnt get this war in WC, lets see if Pak can get itno WC finals without Asif, Aamir and Butt."

They can never win the case at ICC's back yard they have to knock at the door for International court of sports after getting banned by ICC....and by the time all this happens, the world cup trophy will be in someone else's home.

I am pretty sure Mani wud have tackled everything better than Ijaz Butt... Much better than Ijaz Butt :(

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Salman Butt asked to file fresh reply

Updated : Friday December 17 , 2010 3:47:32 PM

LAHORE: The International Cricket Council has rejected Salman Butt’s reply on charges of spot-fixing against him and has asked the suspended Pakistan captain to file a fresh response by Friday.

The ICC on Thursday returned the 40-page reply filed by Butt’s lawyers to the charges laid out against him.

“The ICC said the reply was not acceptable to them and it was just enough to reject the allegations made against him by the ICC anti-corruption unit,” Aftab Gul a lawyer said on Friday.

Gul, who was on Butt’s legal team, also made it clear he had finally withdrawn from representing the former captain as had another lawyer Shahid Saeed.

“As far as I know now Aitzaz Ahsan is handling his case,” Gul said.

Sources said the ICC, in a terse reply to Butt, said it was not amused by his strong worded and hard hitting reply that was sent to them earlier this week.

“Butt has now been told to send a fresh reply to the chargesheet by later tonight despite it being a public holiday in Dubai as well in Pakistan due to Ashura,” a source disclosed.

Butt’s lawyer Shahid Saeed, in an earlier statement, said that in the reply filed with the ICC, the former Pakistan captain had rejected all allegations against him.

Saeed had also criticised ICC chief executive Haroon Lorgat for giving a statement on the spot-fixing issue although charges have still not been proven against the three suspended Pakistani players - Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif.

Butt was unavailable for comments but the source said the ICC had indicated that if it didn’t get a fresh reply by late Friday it would be compelled to take a one-sided decision and Butt would lose his right to defend himself.

“Butt is clearly in a tight position right now and since it is a holiday in Pakistan it seems improbable that his lawyers would be able to file a fresh reply by later today.”

Asif and Amir are being represented by different lawyers.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

I see bans on trio now :rolleyes:

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

Too bad that they got caught. Comes from living in the era of media & cell phone cams. Salim Malik & Akram fixed more but court could not find evidence as conclusive as this one.

Re: Salman Butt, Mohammad Amir and Mohammad Asif are likely to be charged

WTH.. what kind of reply ICC is looking from him, the one which says oh i am sorry i did it please pardon me for this.. the guy filed his reply.. you like it or not deal with it... ICC seems to be taking sides in the whole thing, even trying to dictate the replies...