I have read alot of books about Islam and ahadith…i wanna findout about some of the ahadith in sahi bukhari ..for example in one of the ahadith bibi ayesha perform ghusul (astaghfirallah) and theres alot of stuff in sahi bukhari which i cant write here…and most of the stuff is about the intimate relationship of husband and wife ..i wanna know y bibi ayesha dislclose things which shouldnt b disclose to anyone. i dont wanna go in details.are these ahadith true should we believe on these ahadith.im confused sunni though i belong from a very relegious background..pls dont ban me answer my question.
Re: Sahi bukhari
Because there is nothing wrong in discussing such things in a respectful, mindful, and matter-of-fact manner.
Our culture is one such that we are uncomfortable in discussing such things. There's nothing wrong with that either. However, the point is that this is perhaps the source of your confusion.
Re: Sahi bukhari
whats so "astaghfirullah" about performing ghusl?
Re: Sahi bukhari
brother, if i ask u somthing pls dont get upset ok...lets say u r preaching islam..n if someone comes to u and ask u to teach him how to do ghususl will u b teaching him ghusul the same way she did by showing ghusul practically when there was just a see through cloth between her and that person who inquire about the ghusul...though u and me r ordinary muslims but she was the wife of our Prophet pbuh.. ....pls kindly answer my question.
Re: Sahi bukhari
Well, how would you’ve known the Islamic rulings and ways Allah:swt: wanted us to GUIDE about such matters, if it was not disclosed through the Prophet:saw: [and companions]?
Through Islamiat book?
Re: Sahi bukhari
the “man” here happened to be her nephew…
and from where did u get the “see-through” part???
Re: Sahi bukhari
Pray tell me how is this inquiry going to resolve the current dillemas faced by the muslims around the world. Can we not dedicate ourselves to becoming "practsiing" muslims first before questioning nitty gritty details.
Re: Sahi bukhari
bother Kaleem, this inquiry might not solve the current dillemmas face by the muslims around the world but it will certainly help gain better understanding of islam.
Re: Sahi bukhari
The Quran says that the Holy Prophet :saw: is the best example for us to follow in all matters which also inculde intimate matters…Sex and intimate matters are not a taboo subject in Islam…However, one should know how to approach them…
So how can we learn about the intiimate matters related to Islam if they are not discussed as a matter of teaching?
Re: Sahi bukhari
Just because you're so uptight about these issues doesn't mean Islam has to be too. If it wasn't for such detailed and "astaghfurillah" discussions in sahih bukhari, then we would have missed out on a lot of important practices of Islam.
Re: Sahi bukhari
app jo sahe bukharee ki ahdees per aytraz ker rahay pehlay apna or imam bukhare ka maqam zaroor dekh lain
woh shkas jis ki sare zindhe quran or hadees kay ilm hasil kernay per guzree us ko yeh batain nahi malom theen jo ajj app ko samjh agyee?
bhiee bolnay say pehlay apnay garyban main zaroor jhank liya kerain
app nay quran main hazrat maryam ka waqyia perha hay ?
kia quran main Allah talah nay nahi fermaya or jub hazrat maryam ghusal ferma rahee thee to hazrat jibrail
tashreef layee or unhoon nay bibi mariyam ki teraf phoonk mare Allah kay hukam say
ab is main kia buaryee hay .. ahadees ko as it is likha jata hay us main app rado badal nahi ker saktay ..
baqee app jis hadees ka hawala day rahay page number kay sath pore hadees yahan likhain .. is terah adhora kisi cheez ko paish kerna koi munasib kam nahi !