Sa'adat Hasan Manto's letter to Chacha Sam

Entertainment Media
1

Sa’adat Hasan Manto’s letter to Chacha Sam
From his book
[thumb=A]s_h_manto.JPG[/thumb]

[thumb=A]393.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=A]394.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=A]395.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=A]396.JPG[/thumb]
[thumb=A]397.JPG[/thumb]

2

Manto is great!! Its rather eerie that this letter to Uncle sam is still relevant today. Thanks a lot Mr. Ahmad.

3

Great peice of work .Munto is undebate able but i am doubtfull if these are exact words of munto they person who typed this in urdu made lot of urdu mistakes.

4

Its Gr8. :k:

5

MaiN ney simply kitab key safhaat scan kr key post kr diey haiN. jahaN tak mera khial hey yeh bilkul wahee ilfaz haiN jo Manto ney likhey they. Manto key in khatoot maiN jo cheez intehai heran kr deney wali he, wo he is ka andaz e soch/fikr. 1952 maiN is bandey ney Amreeki sayaasat key barey main jo mehsoos kia aor likha tha, wo aaj key dor peh bhee bilkul poora utarta hey.

6

394.jpg 2nd last line read it again dear and check if munto can make that mistake :)

7

that could be a mistake of kitaab nawees
but
394.jpg last line “aesa film” hmmm.. or aisi film ??

I love reading Manto any way:mudhosh:

8

“Tahum” is wrong word instead it should be “ta ke”

“ta ke hum bhi apney studio bhi aisi film bunaien”

9

he was a think tank , a great writer , a great satirist . i simply love to read him again & again

10

What is it all in urdu? Can someone post an English translation pls.?

11

Re: Sa’adat Hasan Manto’s letter to Chacha Sam

Wah

What a fine peice of satire, and still relevent… excellent:k:

Barey logon ki bari batain :lajawab:

12

Re: Sa’adat Hasan Manto’s letter to Chacha Sam

Pure class :k: manto manto hai!

Share Shair ............
13

Re: Sa'adat Hasan Manto's letter to Chacha Sam

Gr8!!!

14

Re: Sa’adat Hasan Manto’s letter to Chacha Sam

Sahukriya Mr. Ahmed for this great sharing, geo;wow saadat Hassan Manto ny yeh khat 1954 main likha th amagar batin aysi hain ky lag rha hy kal hi likha hy:D
PS: Tmam masaail (issues) aj bhi wohi hain .Mullaon ko musalah kerny wali bat bhi khoob ki howa tu yehi Jangy Afghanistan ky baad:chai:

How Paitoo you are
15

Re: Sa'adat Hasan Manto's letter to Chacha Sam

can anyone please translate that.....pretty plz....:(

there is no place for kashmiri pandits
16

Re: Sa’adat Hasan Manto’s letter to Chacha Sam

X2 ya SS yeh zimadari ahsan tareeqy sy nibha sakty hain:chai: