I would actually want even my 1st ( n last IA) wedding like that. I guess its upto you , its your choice. If she wants to keep it simple, you all should support her and help making it easy for her. Coz your desires do not come first. Its her wedding let her decide. May be you can keep a family get together after the wedding, like after a week or so. She will be in light and good mood by then and happily participate.
If she is only hesitant coz of what ppl will say, then that shows simple wedding is not what she actually wants. Well in that case tell her that ppl are not important and they will do their job of gossiping no matter what she decides to do. If she wants simple wedding they ll say, “hi bechari ka dill toota hoowa hai. Saadha sa nikah karwa rahi hai tsk tsk tsk… etc. And if she goes for a full fledge wedding with all rasams etc, then they will say, " Daikho tou aisay khush hai jaisay pehli shadi hai.”
Both of above comments are useless and going to do no harm to her.